SSIN belittles the struggles of women
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-02-12Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
2,000 women take on the state at Greenham. Common. and rave at men, winning their argu- disgraceful that SSiN can peddle an ment only on the grounds of making argument which lays the blame for the male sex feel guilty. These poor sexual harassment at women's feet! have the ideas of pettv-bourgeois Eight for working class women Anti-working One of our comrades, Phil Penn, has been jailed for 12 months, 8 months of it suspended, for -assault. He is a highly respected member of our Central Committee, a party member for 18 years, active in the trade union movement and recently in campaigns such as that on the Guildford 4 Our concern in this case is that members of another organisation claiming to be part of the labour movement were, apart from the arresting officers, the only police Witnesses. This would be like miners giving evidence against miners in the recent strike.| As you may know in October 1985 the Workers Revolutionary Party expelled its former leader, Gerry Healy, for sexual abuse, violence and slanders against members of the organisation - charges he never contested. A small group of party functionaries including Corin and Vanessa Redgrave, Sheila Torrance and Richard Price, supported Healy and were expelled by the majority. This group then formed a bogus party calling itself the Workers' Revolutionary Party' and publishing newspaper "Newsline' Phil Penn was arrested and charg ed after a demonstration called by the print unions at Wapping on 3 May 1986. The events as reported in court were as follows. In the Newsline of 1 May 1986 the Workers Notebook' column carried a crude and provocative attack on Phil, insulting his intellect and presenting him as ignorant and illiterate, speaking in grunts.
On the 3 May Wapping March, as the conflict between demonstrators and police became increasingly fierce, Phil went to fetch his camera. Once away from the main body of demonstrators he came across members of the Healy-Torrance group. They verbally abused him, taunting him with quotes trom the above-mentioned article. He refused to be provoked. Four of them -Richard Price, Eric Rogers, Paul Williams and another man - then attacked him physically - in Price's case, with banner poles — and knocked him to the ground. In defending himself Phil damaged the eye of one of his assailants. Only Phil was -me: 20p:
Saturday October 11, 1986 Number 3160 Healy's rag arrested.
No organisation calling itself socialist would collaborate with the police against members of the labour movement. This is a point of principle. But members of the HealyTorrance group eagerly acted as police witnesses. Three of the four men who attacked Phil did not appear in court, but two women members of the Healy-Torrance group gave evidence which Phil vigorously contested. Had he been found guilty on the charge of wounding with intent he would have undoubtedly been given a much longer custodial sentence.
This is not the first time the HealyTorrance group have acted in this way. Six of them appeared as police witnesses in Sheffield Crown Court in January this year after an incident between themselves and members of the International Communist Party. On this occasion the court did not believe them, and a defendant was found not guilty.
We should point out that members of the Healy-Torrance group again attacked and beat up Phil Penn on 8 June 1986 in Leicester. They used sticks and knives. The police wished to prosecute his attackers but, as a matter of principle, Phil retused to act as a witness and the case could not go forward We are asking all labour movement organisations to condemn the anti-working class actions of the HealyTorrance group, which were responsible for the jailing of Phil Penn. Messages of support and enquiries should be sent to: Workers Revolution Party/Workers' Press, PO Box 735, London SW9 7QS.
Yours fraternally, DAVE TEMPLE Chair, WRP/WP This article by Sarah Mann originally appeared in CLPD Bulletin and was February 6). A reply Jane Ashworth will follow next week.
To coincide with NUS Conference, held in December 1986, Jane Ashworth and Michele Carlisle of SSiN (Socialist Students in NOLS) produced an article entitled "Feminism Yes, Femocracy No!" (Socialist Organiser, 4 December 1986).
This outlined their position as to whether class or sex is the greater op. pressor. The article is both misleading and crude, and underlies SSIN's decision to abandon their former policy of support for women's autonomy. At 1987 NOLS Conference, they will now be calling on Conference as a whole to elect the Women's Officer, rather than women themselves.
SSiN is a Socialist Organiser-based organisation and their decision is no more than sectarian; a means of ensuring the election of a Socialist Organiser candidate. If this means forfeiting the principle of women's autonomy, then this they are prepared to do.
What is femocracy?
SSiN begin by examining the nature of the word *femocracy which they define as "a stealing of feminism and using it for personal career advancement". Femocrats are compared with bureaucrats and we are told of their reluctance to actually work within the labour movement.! Throughout the article, the implication is that 'femocrats' have no real desire to fight alongside men for left men are forced to retreat and women foisted upon them, because failure to accept these ideas would lead to female intimidation of men.
This in itself is ludicrous. How many meetings do we attend where women speak for at least half the time, or even speak in relation to their numbers? Most political debate is by men, and about male experience. Mos: women would teel too intimidated to speak out. And even if they did, and dared to call a man "sexist' in public, the likely consequence would be the labelling of the woman as neurotic and 'hysterical'. If SSiN really believe that women have got the monopoly on the discuseyes.
Slandering men?
NSiN' (riticisms have no limits Femocrats, they tell us, have no objection to using their gender as a means of slandering men. We are told that femocrats invest incidents of sexual harassment, not just to win political arguments but to "score points". SSiN openly say that femocrats indulge in ruining men's reputations with accusations of harassment, justifying it as "fair game".
This is blatantly misogynist, and adds weight to the myth that women are mentally unbalanced and have nothing better to do that shout I'm being sexually harassed'. We only need to take the argument one step further and we have a situation where it's plausible to say 'women shout rape for the fun of it"
In actual fact most women are frightened to reveal cases of sexual harassment for fear of adverse publicity and the knowledge that they will have to relive the incidents over and over again in their minds instead of trying to forget them. Sexual harassment affects all women, and is not taken seriously enough. lt is SSiN's position can be summarised in an outrageously simplified paragraph stating that: "the power that a working class man has over a working class woman is absolutely negligible when compared to the murdering, decadent, crushing power of the international ruling class." Try telling that to a working class woman who's being battered behind doors by her working class husband! This article is now taking on a Militant/SWP outlook: that we should only fight for working class women, and not because they are women, but because they are members of the working class! Let me remind you, SSiN -rape affects all women; abortion affects all women. And it's not just working class women who are afraid to walk the streets at night! No liberation without socialism Whilst we accept that there can be по women's liberation without socialism, it is no longer enough to say that female oppression is going to disappear overnight. Instead of attacking women, relentlessly, we could do better to examine and criticise the behaviour of men in the Labour Left, for they are not without faults. It is important to remember that there can be no socialism without women's liberation.
SiN's article on femocracy belittles women on the Labour Left and tries to invalidate our experience as women. Women are portrayed as essentially apolitical, hostile to the Idea of class contliet, and disınterested in promoting real struggle. SSiN say that we can do without femocracy or femocrats. Rather, I would say that the Labour Left can do without this type of spiteful, sectarian and misogynistic writing. If SSiN want to build alliances for socialism, they'll have to do better than this, for essentially it amounts to nothing more than petty-minded, Daily Mail-type lies.
----- pull-quotes -----
reprinted by Socialis Action (no. 158,