[A new six-part series on women started this…]
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-02-12Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
A new six-part series on women started this week on ITV at the unusual hour of 12.30 pm.
It looks at half the world's population" , how women's lives have changed, their present situation and our hopes for the future.
If you've ever watched daytime telon the women throughout the world.
Did you know that women do 65% of the world's work but own 1% of its property and receive 10% of its income? 33% of the world's women are illiterate, only 37% go to primary school and 75% of the women in underdeveloped countries are underfed.
Yet in Africa women grow 75% of the food produced, do 50% of the planting of crops and 75% of the weeding in the fields. (By the way, The cheap labour force in the Third World is predominantly made up of women, most of whom are between 18 and 21. They work 18 hour shifts in sweat shops doing boring and tiring manufacturing work.
For some the meagre wage provides the essentials - like food and shelter for their children. The programme showed how this "independence" just getting out of the home — can give the women a tremendous confidence boost. Based on Umberto Eco's novel of the same name, The Name of the Rose is a mediaeval whodunnit — or rather, who is doing it.
An ex-inquisitor, now a monk, (Sean Connery) arrives at an Italian monastery as part of a delegation of Franciscans preparing to do theological battle with Benedictine emissaries of the Pope over the vexed issue of whether Christ owned his own loin cloth. Brother William, accompanied by his scribe Adso, a young novice, discovers that monks are being murdered in gruesome ways, and sets about unearthing the mystery.
The monastery has a secret: and it is clear that the murders are connected in some way to it. And it seems that the abbey's huge library contains the secret. So William and Adso begin an investigation that is to take them to many strange discoveries.
Eco's novel is really a fantastic pot pourri of different ingredients. A mystery worthy of Agatha Christie is woven into a complex account of clerical history, arcane theological debates (although the question of whether Jesus laughed or not turns out to be more important than you think...), sexual repression, and a terrifying confrontation between heretics and the Papal inquisitor.
By Edward Ellis The film treats all of this remarkably well. Of course the story has to be simplified to a considerable extent, and in a few respects has been altered (detrimentally, I thought). But on the whole it is a faithful reproduction of the book, executed with great atmospheric style. Like the novel, the film almost smells of a fourteenthcentury monastery. It is very well It is a profound as well as an exciting, story. William has abandoned the inquisition because he can no longer be sure what is true and what is false, nor what is heresy and what orthodoxy.
Gui the Inquisitor has none of his qualms: he is determined to send two members of a virtually extinct sect (who had tried to physically exterminate the rich) and an innocent girl to burn at the stake, merely to serve the factional interests of the Pope.
But the real power of this part of the story comes from its twentieth century relevance. The inquisition did not die out with the Dark Ages. No historically aware socialist can read or watch Gui's trial of the heretics without thinking of the Moscow purges in the 1930s. I'm sure that the obscure stories of the different Catholic schisms must strike a chord, as well.
Eco's novel is an indictment not only of the inquisition and the mediaeval church, not only of intolerance, but of heresyhunting more generally. The film keeps the horror of the unchallengeable inquisitor and the burnings at the stake. But perhaps it loses the subtleties.
Nevertheless, it is a well-made and arresting picture.
February 1987. Page 9.