Israel and chauvinism
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-02-12Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
Socialist Organiser no.302. 12th February 1987. Page 4: TRUST.
One GENER NECKINNOCK ELECTIO CONTINVES LOCMS -HUNT - SOFT IN THE 5LAH! кегокмІмʼя мо ANSWER! BLURGH! LEAVE THE LAGOUR PARTY!.. ER. BRRR! 'S COLD - GLAD I'VE GOT ME BUNKERS TO KEEP ME WARM.
HEAD.... Adam Woolf in SO 296 is quite wrong to say that John O'Mahony is in any way "condoning racist oppression". Even so there are some points John made I'd like to comment on.
Socialist Organiser takes a 'two states' position on the Middle East. Why? Not because we support Israeli national chauvinism, but because we recognise the national rights of the Israeli and Palestinian peoples. That leads us to reject the formula of a military conquest of Israel.
SO supporters do not condone racism: we take the lead of Lenin on the national question in supporting national rights; but that should not lead us to support the state of Israel in the way John O'Mahony seems to.
What we want is class unity for a socialist federation of the Middle East. Recognising those national rights lays a basis for building that unity. We want to smash the Israeli state only so far as we want to smash all "States" , in as much as they are mechanisms for oppression.
The yes/no choice O'Mahony seems to offer ignores that there is more than one alternative. It ignores that our 'support' for Israel to exist is based on our opposition to that blood-bath, not on support for Israeli-Jewish oppression and chauvinism, nor because we see Israel's existence as the best possible state of affairs in the Middle East.
Yours comradely, DUNCAN CHAPEL Newcastle-upon-Tyne
Scan page 5
Poster by the German anti-Nazi artist of the 1930s, John Heartfield The dance of death by Felix Nussboum