Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Racism and racialism

Socialist Organiser no. 302, 12 February 1987 · scan p. 4 · about 520 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

Jean Lane's 'Women's Eye' article on hidden racism seems to me to contain some very misleading notions.

Central to Jean's argument is the idea that "racism goes far deeper than the attacks on the streets, the firebombs through letter boxes, the exclusion from jobs and houses. These actions are in the open. They can be fought..."

*But how do you join together to fight the 'tut'; the weary look to the heavens; the hidden, insiduous body language and mental attitudes of practically every single white person who passes you in the street?' Is Jean seriously telling us that being tutted at is as serious a matter as being firebombed? Or that "insidious body language" is comparable with being denied a job because of your Perhaps the tuts and the body language are actually worse than the firebombs? After all, firebombs are "'in the open". You stand with them.

Last year, in Socialist Organiser, Payman Rezai wrote an excellent series of articles (based upon a piece by A. Sivanandan in 'Race and Class' magazine) criticising this approach to anti-racism. He cited the Rampton Report, the Scarman Report and Racism Awareness Training (RAT) as examples of "the same identification of racism with personal attitudes and behavioural problems" — an analysis which rests upon a "sociopsychological" or even *sociobiological" view of racism.

Structures

Payman Rezai referred to Sivanandan's argument that some of the original confusion in RAT thinking can be overcome by clarifying the terms we use. 'Racism' strictly speaking should be used to refer to structures and institutions with power to discriminate. Individuals the other hand display in their at titudes racialism"!

This seems to me to be more than just a pedantic distinction: the failure to distinguish between institutionalised/state racism and organised racist activity on the one hand, and individual racialist attitudes (that, no doubt, we all harbour to some extent) leads to a wrong understanding of what racism is and of how to fight it.

It accounts, for instance, for the counter-productive, bureaucratic "anti-racism from above" approach of many Left Labour Councils.

It also means that we fail to distinguish between organised racists who must be fought on the streets, if necessary, and individuals with backward ideas, who can be argued with and won over.

Jean says "the majority of white racists in Britain are not attackers or firebombers. They are people who have been brought up to assume that they are naturally superior because they have a white skin — fed on racist history, racist language, brought up on a diet of narrow-mindedness and ignorance."

Such a definition of racism would almost certainly include the vast majority of the working class of Britain. We cannot treat them as though they were organised racists, the tascists, the police, the Tories or racist employers.

Having said that, I think Jean was quite right to shout at the woman on the bus!

Yours, FLOYD O BRIEN More letters p. 10.

Send letters to Socialist Organiser, PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA. Please try to keep your letters below 300words, or we may have to cut. them for reasons of space.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 302

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →