Tribune celebrates its 50th birthday
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-02-12Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 3
Socialist Organiser no. 302. 12th February 1987. Page 3.
"Tribune' this week has been celebrating its fiftieth birthday.
Contributions from ex-editors, retired trade union leaders, dead novelists, and Mikhail Gorbachev (writing in detail to UN Secretary General, Perez de Cuellar on 'how the Soviet Union marked the year of peace') are introduced by the paper's recently departed editor, Nigel Williamson.
In 1985, as he recalls, Williamson wrote a 'mini-manifesto' which was "an admission that the left had advanced as far as it could under existing circumstances.
He was criticised, Williamson remembers among others by Socialist Organiser. "Yet despite all the criticism, I felt elated. It was an PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA. 01-639 7965 alest diate for report. Bost Plondaviority phone. Monday eye ing Editor John a mahony Typesetting: Upstream Ltd (TU).
MORE SE zn$2B.
London SE15 4NA ripted by Fau Chokee Registered as a newspaper at the Post Office. signed articles winDE ecessardy retinct them emero SocialistOrganiser. elation born of freedom." He was free of left-wing myths: "One of the first to be thus demolished was the riduculous notion that there were no 'enemies' on the left and that any attempts to curb the organised infiltration of the Labour Party by Trotskyist groups... had to be resisted."
Thus liberated, Williamson - who let the beans be spilled, used to contribute to Socialist Organiser and was even a supporter's card carrier for a while - pitched himself into the witch-hunt, his conscience salved.
Sordid
IF is a rather sordid little confession. It is made more sordid still -and pathetic too - by the embarrassing prediction that 1987 will be "the year which sees the election of the first Tribune Prime Mininster.' Williamson still believes that Neil Kinnock is an ally of 'the left' it seems. Poor Nigel. Sharing the heritage of all those ex-editors, dead novelists and Soviet presidents has sadly gone to his head. As the saying goes — those who do not learn from history are likely to wind up repeating it.
Tribune began life 50 years ago as a Stalinist-hued Labour Party advocate of the Communist Party line known as the Popular Front.
The Popular Fronters, inside the Labour Party and outside advocated not a Labour Government but a coalition government involving also the Liberals and the CP. Rather like the present line of 'Marxism Today' and the Communist Party. As Trotsky pointed out in 1939, these 'left wingers' were to the right of the rightist official Labour Party leaders, who at least wanted a straight Labour government, In the "40s Tribune moved to the right and then in the later forties it was associated with the 'Keep Left' group of Labour MPs.
In the early '50s, when Nye Bevan, Harold Wilson and John Freeman resigned from the Labour government in protest at the imposition of charges for NHS prescriptions, it was the organ of the left wing Bevanite movement, which developed powerful following in the Labour Pary and the Unions.
Tribune stood up to Aneurin Bevan when he condemned unilateralism in 1957.
Tribune's greatest moment came when the Labour Party conference in 1960 voted to make unilateral nuclear disarmament Party policy. Tribune was at the head of that movement in the Labour Party. So was Michael Foot.
But the PLP, led by Hugh Gaitskell revolted against Party policy and threatened to split. Tribune and Foot didn't fight back - They retreated and started to advocate that Britain and NATO should pledge never to strike first, instead of unilateralism. (That is what it came down to in practice)
Blows Not suprisingly, the fight forced through an anti-unilateralist resolution at the 1961 conference.
New blows were to follow, Party leader Hugh Gaitskell died suddenly and in early 1963 Bevan's one-time collegue, Harold Wilson, was elected leader. Whereas the honest right-winger Hugh Gaitskell had confronted and frequently outraged the left, Wilson knew how to make faking left noises to keep them in line. Soon he had Tribune in tow.
After Wilson formed a government in 1967 and through to the election of 1970, Tribune remained in tow. It protested here and there and grumbled against the government, but it could do nothing and didn't Tribune's circulation and influence plummeted. The traditional Labour left collapsed in the later 1960s. Events on the left passed Tribune by. It shrivelled to the status of an institution, a fake left cover and an occasional platform for one-time leftist Ministers and ex-ministers, such as Stan Orme and Michael Foot.
and Chris Mullin took over. That was the time when the left in the Labour Party was explosively challenging the Party establishment which had lost the 1979 election after 5 years in government.
Mullin was a commited supporter of Tony Benn and he made Tribune a vigorous paper of the Bennite left. For the first time in 30 years Tribune showed signs of life.
When Williamson succeeded Mullin the labour movement was in retreat, and Tribune reverted to what it had been — a paper slightly on the outside of the left establishment, pushing essentially tame and safe ideas.
Today's editor Williamson suffers from the delusion that the left is the establishment - Kinnock will be a Tribune PM. Yes, maybe he will, but only in the sense that if Kinnock becomes PM, Tribune will be to him what it was to Wilson - a tame opposition.
It would be better, comrade Williamson, to learn the lesson of Tribune's history than to repeat one of the worst episodes in that far from glorious past.
-But there are too many of our employees whose lives have been scarred by these "innocent" printers and too many police officers who bear the marks of their violence for us simply to turn the other cheek...
*We know from your hundreds, possibly thousands, of letters to us that you above all others knew exactly what was at stake in this dispute:
whether - in a free society - a bunch of thugs should be allowed to deprive you of the paper you want."
And so on and so on ad nauseam.
Classier
The Times likes to think of itself as a bit classier than the Sun. Whether it really is, or whether it is just more hypocritical and a bit more literate, Is a matter for conjecture. Friday's editorial (Hard Lessons of Wapping)
pontificated on about "freedom"
"strife" and "damaging trade union practices"
'The time has not yet come for the full history of this dispute to be written. The temptation to reach instant conclusions about its importance in itself, and the importance of extremists in its course, must be resisted," droned the "Thunderer' Interestingly, neither the Sun, or the Times, nor Sunday's News of the World (which described NUJ General' Secretary Harry Conroy as a "stupid bully" and called on him to resign) made any mention at all of the person who did most to ensure Murdoch's victory: Eric Hammond.
No doubt Hammond is grateful for this diplomatic silence. When the time does come for "the full history of this dispute to be written Erie and his cronies in the EETPU leadership might find they have a little explaining to de. But don't expect to read about it in the Sun or the Times.
Meanwhile, I suppose I'll have to carry on reading Murdoch's garbage. Still it makes the Guardian and Today and even the Star seem like quite r. de papered must bet going soft.
Scan page 4
• LETTER
----- pull-quotes -----
Then in 1980, Richard Clements left the editor's chair, after 20 years,