Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

New Tory anti-union laws

Socialist Organiser no. 302, 12 February 1987 · scan p. 2 · Jane Ashworth · about 893 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 2

what's the answer?

House prices! Centre

= divide IODAY The great sta MONEY EXTRA Edward CASTRATE HIM Better street-lighting and easily anvone who has had their dole cut for conference. The Tories are threatening new anti-union laws designed to control the power of union leaders.

"Reforms" would include government-appointed 'watchdog' to oversee closed shop complaints' and 'politically motivated intimidation'; compulsory secret ballots before strikes; forcing unions to open their accounts to scrutiny by their members; and compulsory threeyearly elections for union executives.

The tragedy is that the Tory "reforms' seem to address some problems in union democracy. Union executives should be elected much more frequently - no one should have a job for life as a union leader.

Union officials should be paid only the average of their members, and members should be able to recall Ra JUSTIFIED public outrage followed a judge's decision last week to give the longest sentence in the 'vicarage rape' case to the man who didn't rape. -Gang leader Robert Morscroft got 14 years for burglary and grievous bodily harm, while his accomplices got 5 and 3 years for rape plus 5 years each for burglary.!

The sentences indicate the attitude of the judge — who is typical of the legal system. The vicar who had been beaten by the rapists complained: "It was like a gentlemen's club in court... I am frankly appalled at the lack of understanding evident in some of the statements made by the judge and some of the barristers".

That the legal system in Britain holds property as more important than people has thus been put into sharp relief, because all the men were involved in the same case., But we should not allow the beat them, hang them, and castrate them" lobby to use the justified anger at these sentences for reactionary ends. That is how the entire popular press, and Mrs Thatcher herself, are using the vicarage case.

Power

New laws are to be rushed through Parliament to give the Court of Appeal power to probe cases which cause 'public outcry' • The court will be able to name lenient judges, and order other courts to give harsher sentences.

But what is a public outery"? Often public outcries are orchestrated by the press, by politicians, or by others pulling strings. Many things that deserve an outcry are covered up.

Policemen who kill people are always dealt with very leniently. Will there be 'outcries' and investigations there? For certain there will not.

By Frank them and have new elections whenever the officials don't do their job properly.

Details of union financing should be available to all members.

But these are issues that should be dealt with by the union rank and file themselves. Government-imposed "democracy' is not democracy at all: its purpse is to control the unions from above, and that will be its effect. Compulsory ballots, for example, slow down decisions - making short-notice strikes almost impossible.

And backed up by the rest of the Tories' anti-union laws, these new 'reforms' restrict the unions' ability to act. If there are innumerable legal restrictions to consider - and so the 8-PAGE PULL-OUT available alarms for women might help reduce rape. There should be more public funding for Rape Crisis Centres.

But we also need to think of new forms of justice.

System

The present judiciary is tied to an Establishment that loves no freedom as much as the freedom to buy and sell. Its laws are in essence laws defending property - it is an offence to steal a loaf of bread if you are starving, but quite legal to throw thousands of people onto the scrap heap; there is no law against homelessness or poverty, The inequality of women is built into the legal system, too - as From page 1 threat of legal action, sequestration for failing to comply, and so on -reven 100% democratic unions would find it hard to act swiftly and decisively in their members' interests.

Democracy in the unions means democracy for the rank and file — relying on their own organisation, not on the law and the courts. The complete independence of the unions from the state is the basis for real democracy.

Labour should reject these new Tory proposals, campaign against them in the general election and pledge that it will repeal all the existing laws, and implement laws defending trade union independence — the right to strike, to picket, to defend picket lines. And rank and file militants need to organise to fight for democracy.

net in the vicarage raid 'cohabitation' can testify., This legal system can and should be reformed to give women more protection from rapists — and more redress. Longer sentences are probably not the best form of redress, since they might reduce the likelihood of the guilty being convicted.

But, fundamentally, no reform can win genuine freedom for women from rape and the threat of it. Only the total transformation of society -the destruction of the present relauons or power over women by men which lead to rape — can change that.!

A new form of justice, based on working-class communities, defending people not property, would be a first step towards that fundamental change.

----- pull-quotes -----

* Horror at the vicarager i Victim joins outrage ato -soft' rape sentencesy MY LAW WOULD BE TO

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 302

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →