Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Lifting the veil off Liverpool Militant

Socialist Organiser no. 301, 5 February 1987 · scan p. 10 · Alan Johnson · about 2,039 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

Liverpool city council march, June 1985. Photo John Martin Thomas spoke on behalf of the Editorial Board of Socialist Organiser at meeting in London to commemorate Nahuel Moreno, the Argentine Trotskyis who died last week This is the text of his address.

Every generation of revolu tionaries stands on the shoulder of those before it.

We stand on the shoulders of thos who maintained the Trotskyist move ment in the difficult days of the 1950 and early '60s. Nahuel Moreno, al Argentine Trotskyist who died week, was one of them.

1948-56 was perhaps the lowest ebl point for revolutionary Marxisn since the 1860s. Most Trotskyist dropped out of activity. Only th most tenacious remained - peopl like Moreno. We all owe them a debt whatever our political difference with them.

They were trying to grapple witl great problems. In our view they fail ed to a large extent. That is why, a Moreno himself said in an interviev last year, we have today a barbari form of Trotskyism. It is easier to ser now with hindsight than it was ther in the maelstrom; but since we have hindsight we must use it and lear from it.

The root of the problems was this After 1948, with the decline in th post-war working-class ferment, th cold war, and the Communist Par ties' left turn, the Trotskyists wer isolated. Yet at the same time, ir Yugoslavia, China, Korea, and Viet nam, the revolution they had fough for, or some form of it, seemed to br going forward nonetheless.

Stalinism, so it turned out, was be ing revolutionary against capitalisn while simultaneously counter revolutionary against the working class.

The comrades tried to fit this inte their perspectives. The answer they came up with at the Third World Congress of the Trotskyist movement in 1951 was this: there was an objec tive process of world revolution ad vancing, which would express itsell through whatever force was at hand if no revolutionary workers' move ment existed.

Blocs

This did not mean that they forgot about the working class. They thought that unless and until the working class intervened the revolutionary process would be delayed and distorted, It did not mean that they necessarily tailed to work in the working class - and Moreno built an organisation of some thousands in the Argentine working class.

It did mean, inescapably, that the class struggle became less central to their politics than a struggle of blocs or camps on the world scale. Politics was primarily a matter of the struggle class as only i camp off Sped ine percepno among the ta among them.

The Revolutionary - Proletariat*, for the Stalinist ndred times more the bourgeois that what he thought he was doing was defending the nationalised property relations, and the Stalinist-led revolutions, against the cold-war right-wing.

But what he said was wrong, and, despite his intentions, very far from the politics of Trotsky, who in the Transitional Programme described Stalin's political regime as differing from fascism "only in its more unbridled savagery"

In 1982 Socialist Organiser had a sharp difference with Moreno over the South Atlantic war. We gave him a page of our paper to explain his views, and we debated the issue.

We agreed that socialists must oppose Britain's war. For ourselves, we had "The enemy is at home' as a banner on our paper throughout the war.

But we believed that Galtieri's war was equaily predatory, equally imperialistic though at a lower level of capitalist power. The junta's war could not benefit the workers of Argentine, or in any way improve their conditions for struggle against the multinationals, the international banks and the Argentine capitalists who exploit them.

War The war was only a political diversion and a power-play by the military rulers.

We understood that socialists in Argentina, finding themselves in the midst of a tide of mass nationalisam, would have to adapt their agitation to the mood of the workers. But we could not agree with calling for national unity of all classes for the war, or for the unions to open recruiting offices for Galtieri's army, as Moreno did. Even if you supported Argentina, for a Trotskyist that should mean n national unity with the junta — jus as when Trotsky supported China against Japan in the 1930s, he did not preach unity with Chiang Kai Shek, In his polemic against us Moreno said that the Falkland Islanders had no more rights than the Jews in Palestine or the English settlers - as he called the Protestants - in Ireland. We could not agree with this attitude to the rights of minorities. It is no part of the programme of socialism to sweep away such minorities.

But — to conclude - what was the significance of this dispute? There is no doubt that Moreno sincerely believed that his positions served the cause of anti-imperialism and thus of socialism. He was serving our common ideals as he saw best in the ideological framework that he had learned 35 or 40 years ago, the barbaric form of Trotskyism.

We are all still barbarians, more or less, compared to the classic Marxism of Lenin and Trotsky. That Marxism has only just begun its Renaissance after its Dark Ages.

What we need now is not only, and not primarily, an organisational regroupment of the forces of Trotskyism, but a political and theoretical regeneration. That will be a long task, possible only through patient and comradely discussion and comparison of experiences.

Nahuel Moreno Simon Lawlor, unimpressed by Bas Hardy's review of *The Racial Politics of Militant in Liverpool' (SO 1296) asks us to find "someone who deals with facts' before we take On Militant's record on race and racism again (SO 297), Simon says "On housing, in Liverpool 8, the Council has spent more on its housing budget than any other local authority's total housing budget." No one is disputing how vital and significant is the council's Urban Regeneration Scheme. But that doesn't settle the matter.

In 1984 a survev of housing in Liverpool, financed by the Commission for Racial Equality, was published by Liverpool University. It showed clearly that the city's system for allocating council houses concentrated blacks in limited areas of the city and gave them poorer quality accommodation than whites.

The team which produced the report, headed by the city's Housing manager Mr John King recommended a whole series of measures to combat what it called "conscious or unconscious stereotyping of black applicants by Housing Officers and the unintentional racist effect of allocation procedures and practices"

What has happened since? First of all the Housing Manager was suspended. Why? No formal evidence has ever been brought against him.

And "when the details of the new allocations system emerged there was practically no reference to race within it and no mechanisms whatsoever were adopted to ensure the new system was monitored, to remove the sources of proven racial bias, or to redress the balance of proven racial inequality."

Look at the way the council prevented the River Avon Street sheltered house scheme in 1984. The project, with 75% of its funding already agreed from central government, was to provide sheltered accommodation for elderly members of ethnic minority groups. After extensive consultation with community groups, at the last minute - when £100,000 was already spent - the council pulled the plug. The explanation can be found in Tony Byrne's words of two years before, opposing accommodation for elderly Chinese:

**This working party is of the opinion that hostels for the elderly should be provided to meet the needs of the local community as a whole and not for any particular ethnic group."

"On the question of jobs, over 20% of all new intakes have been black" says Simon. Now I'd like to know where you plucked that figure from. I'm looking at a set of statistics for Liverpool City Council appointments, June 1984 to September 1985. It says that 96.7% were white and 3.3% black, I'm also looking at this year's Community Relations Council report which says that no coherent information of black employment has been available for consideration either inside or outside the authority in the last 18 months"

Most depressing of all, Simon repeats all the myths about the Black Caucus: that it is 'unrepresentative" sides with the liberals and bishops and that it is just "cheesed off that they haven't landed a well paid job". What's the truth here?

The Black Caucus is simply those people from the black community who are elected, each year, by community organisations to represent "stS TS ONSCRIPT BULL Smith, IFL. chem on the Race Relations Liaison Committee, a body fought for by the black community. They were held to be the authentic representatives by all political parties, including Labour, right up to the Bond appointment. Why else did they have three after it vigorously opposed the appointment of a totally inexperienced building surveyor from Brent to the post of Principal Race Relations Advisor, that it became,literally overnight, 'unrepresentative' 'selfinterested', a "clique' , etc, (and in the poisonous oral propaganda peddled by Militant amongst the youth, "pimps and gangsters").

The council argued: "The Tories oppose the City Council, the Caucus oppose the City Council, so the Caucus are Tories'. Simon falls headlong into this trap.

It must be said that Militant were not the only "Marxists" to come out of the episode with a sullied reputation. The Socialist Workers Party will be permanently marked by their volte-face on the question.

In November 1984 the SWP were marching through Liverpool on the 'No more Bond-age' march organised by the Caucus. In May 1985 came the SWP's marriage proposal to Militant — "there is a basis for working together to build a viable socialist alternative. Do you agree?"

By Autumn 1985 they were writing such abject nonsense as Militant have good reason for calling themselves revolutionary rather than reformist. In all respects, except their adherence to the Labour Party their programme and policies belong to the Trotskyist tradition".

By September 1986 Alex Callinicos, a leading Sw member, was describing the Caucus as a group of community workers who have set themselves up as the representatives of the people of Toxteth" - Callinicos demanded people take a stand on "the antics of the caucus".

He couldn't give a Castlemaine about where the council stood on the by now hostile and alienated black community — after all the organisational imperative was 'getting close to the Militant?

And then, just recently, the SWP line changed again. All of a sudden, Militant had become "a small sect" which had "abandoned the Trotskyist legacy, i.e. the October Revolution and the first four conlita gresses of the Third International"; and after all, "building the revolutionary alternative in Britain requires making a complete break with their The whole episode was a sordid display of the art of tailoring your politics to the demands of the organisational-manoeuvre, glorified as 'the art of stick-bending' . Ordinary SWP members should reflect on the leadership that supervised it.

Simon used to know that Militant operate on the basis of a crude, economistic view of the world where the divisions that exist among British workers — especially of race and sex are insignificant ones, Where the structures of the movement, which are for us in need of drastic overhaul, are tine by them. Where only the continual propagation of the 'bold socialist programme' is needed.

Mixed into this brew is an organisational arrogance and a political method marked by its bitter and blinkered sectarianism to other groups and campaigns; techniques of distortion; and now the use of local government patronage as a means of political control.

This is part of the historical legacy of Stalinism. It is not Trotskyism, That's what Bas Hardy meant when he wrote, in his flowery way to be sure, but with truth: "Militant is a semi-religious, crypto-Stalinist sect which pushes a half-baked brand of mutated Stalinism."

LIVERPOOL A SOCIALIST ORGANISER PAMPHLET 20р Available rom SO, PO Box 823, London SI 15. 20p plus postage.

----- pull-quotes -----

between Imneria on one side, and Revol Forms on the

members with full voting rights on the interview panel? No, it was only

WHAT WENT WRONG?

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 301

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →