A lesson in socialist principles?
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-02-05Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
Socialist Organiser no 301 5 February 1987 page 9 This column is usually devoted to exposing the cant and hypocrisy of the capitalist press, and on more than one occasion the Guardian has been the target of my rapier-like shafts. So it is with genuine pleasure that I draw readers' attention to a really first class piece of political journalism from Hugo Young in Thursday's Guardian:
*If I had to nominate the single most depressing spectacle of the present parliament I would have difficulty in discovering anything to surpass a 15-minute period on Tuesday afternoon. There one saw encapsulated in a few brief exchanges what eight years have done to the idea of liberty and what has happened in that time to the role of the parliamentary opposition as liberty's defender."
Young was referring to the Zircon satellite affair, and the Labour front bench response to the government's attempt to keep it a secret, not just from the plebs like you and I, but from Parliament itself.
Young, a Wapping refusenik who contributes an occasional "Commentary" column to the Guardian on a freelance basis, is no revolutionary. He accepts, for instance, that there is such a thing as "national security" and therefore information that "no editor or television producer or responsible reporter would wish to publish". What appalled Young was the willingness of the Labour front bench to swallow, hook, line and sinker, the government's definition of what constitutes "national security" and therefore justifies the suppression of free journalism. Worse still, the Windbag's terror of being criticised for lack of patriotism, led him to attack Thatcher for not suppressing information about Zircon effectively enough!
"It is perfectly true, of course, that the government has been incompetent in achieving its objectives. It was late in urging the BBC not to complete a film it knew was being made months ago. It was late with its injunction against Duncan Campbell. But have we seriously reached the point where the Labour leader feels that he should be the one to make these points: to make them, indeed, the core of his attack: to demonstrate, it would seem, that an authoritarian prime minister is defective only in the sluggishness and caution she brings to the practice of authoritarianism?"
So what should have been an ideal opportunity to expose this government's innate hatred of free speech, and its contempt even for Parliamentary democracy, was turned into an embarrassing fiasco in which Kinnock tried to out-jingo Thatcher, and - inevitably — failed. Now, as the boys in blue ransack the BBC's Glasgow offices, seizing film, sound recordings and scripts of the entire "Secret Society" series (of which the Zircon programme was just one of six films) Kinnock and Kaufmann hold up their hands in horror. A bit late in the day, you might think. After all, this is more or less what the Windbag called for last Tuesday.
I'll leave the last word to the splendid Hugo Young — the consistent bourgeois democrat who could teach Labour's front bench "socialists" a thing or two about fighting Thatcher:
*They have a real situation in which to show what they are made Campbell of. Given that test, they have revealed how malleable they are, and how slight is their grasp of the principles they pretend to believe in.
beat presenter had shocked the nation's youth by saying something offensive and outrageous whilst advertising 'The Tube'.
Scab
I'm not sure whether I can actually write it here. Already my hand is trembling. Oh, all right, then, I'll do it. He said 'Groovy fuckers'!!
Quick, let me throw this pen away and wash my hands of the sinful deed.
I mean, isn't it a joke? So what if he said 'Groovy fuckers"? What's the matter with being a 'groovy fucker"? I'd rather be a 'groovy fucker' than a scab. But I forget, the controversy is because he is influencing our younger viewers.
Who are these younger viewers? Do they live in a bubble where they don't see violence or hear swear words or have minds of their own?
Many parents give their little Johns guns, and Janets dollies, reinforced by the roles they see on TV. Kids watch the Benny Hill show. Now surely that's downright offensive! Come on, it's 1987, for god's sake.
Lastly, but not leastly: this has got nothing to do with TV, but if my editor permits - have you got your new Labour Party card yet?
Maybe it's just me, but don't you think it looks like a 20p-off coupon from your next purchase of sanitary towels?
Scan page 10
Nahuel Moreno NOISSA