South Africa: the 'necklace' and the struggle in the ton
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-02-05Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
A comrade flees from vigilante and security Anne Mack looks socialists and trad violence in South In 1986 a new word from South Africa entered our vocabulary: the 'necklace"
A 'necklace is a tyre, doused in petrol, placed round someone's head and then set alight. It is a terrible way to die.
"Originally the 'necklace" was used only against collaborators in the black townships, but as 'ungovernability' extended to more and more areas many genuine and committed fighters in the liberation movement became victims of this practice.
Provocateurs
These comrades sometimes died as a result of the activities of agents provocateurs working for the state and posing as "comrades', but more ominously, people have died as a result of the activities of certain groups within the liberation movement, who have chosen to label all who disagree with them as "enemies of the people!
Some muddleheaded radicals in Britain see the widespread use of the 'necklace' as a mark of the revolutionary tempo and nature of the struggle in South Africa. The reality is very different.
Serious socialists and trades union activists inside South Africa have campaigned against the necklace' This extract from the latest edition of Azania Frontline explains why, *On 28 April 1986 two members of the Electrical and Allied Workers Trade Union of South Africa were petrol-bombed to death. According to eye witness accounts they were travelling in a car on their way home from work at about 5.30 in the afternoon. They drove past the Crossroads squatter camp in Cape Town. Then a few young people threw stones at their car causing the driver of the car, Rashid, to accelerate.
The car picked up speed, skidded on the dirt road and smashed into a tree at high speed. While the two trades unionists were seriously injured and trapped inside the car, one of the young people who had been throwing the stones now threw a petrol bomb into the vehicle which immediately started to burn. According to the eye witnesses, Rashid was burnt to death — he was unable to escape because of his serious injuries and also because his chest was tight up against thei steering wheel.
David Ndude, the other trade unionist in the car, sustained 80% burns. He was freed from the car by people who had gathered around the car. However he died a slow and painful death six days later.
A very close comrade of the two murdered trades unionists said that the workers in the region of the Western Cape were outraged by the seemingly meaningless killing of two workers who were themselves victims of exploitation and oppression'. He explained that 'their union felt it had a duty to mount a campaign to stop the kind of anarchy and chaos which has in some townships displaced the discipline and democracy of a movement of liberation'.
A number of people, among them one man who had served a long prison sentence on Robben Island, have been executed by 'necklace'. The comrade of the deceased trades unionists said that their killings:
--cannot be seen in isolation from the necklacing of genuine fighters for national liberation. What started as the killing of apartheid collaborators or sell-outs in time became, in the hands of certain groups, the killing of at the response le unionists to the Africa's black the debate about progressive militants whose only mistake is that their views do not accord with those of the AN or UDF. A number of good comrades were killed and removed from the scene in this way. The killing is not sheer madness because there is method in the madness. The anarchy to which the government contributed its terrorist vigilantes was used by certain groups to label virtually anyone a collaborator, resulting in immediate execution simply because the person so labelled held contrary views about the nature of our struggle. No discussion, no questions asked. People were just grabbed and a tyre doused in petrol placed around the neck and then set on fire to cause a most gruesome death imaginable.'* At a recent press conference in Harare, Oliver Tambo, president of the ANC, said that he does not support the use of the 'necklace' However he also said that he felt unable to condemn those who did use it.
Besides indiscriminate terror and the silencing of political opponents there is another dimension to the 'necklacing' phenomenon.
Very often, oppressed workers who have not been properly organised and therefore fail to support some call to action such as a consumer boycott, can find themselves facing very severe punishment. It has become common practice, for instance, for people breaking consumer boycotts of white businesses to be forced to eat the products from white stores that the 'comrades' may find in their possession. This often includes soap powder and cooking oil, According to the editorial in the A number of people, among them one man Robben Island have been executed by the "necklace"
left wing South African journal Work in Progress:
-There have been defeats too. Undisciplined comrades, often acting with no organisational basis or mandate, have divided communities, setting workers against the unemployed, children against parents, trades unions against community groups.
"Some of the rent boycotts have been enforced with a high degree of anti-democratic authoritarianism. The youth have often acted without the organisational structures necessary for democratic decision-making, and without adequate mandate or consultation. Recourse to 'discipline' — "necklacings' ', beatings and other punishments — has come too easily to a group which often lacks a mandate to act on behalf of any major constituency.
The point here is not to oppose in principle the use of coercion in imposing the discipline of the popular movement, but to point out that most *coercion' and 'discipline' is carried out by groups with no real democratic mandate.
This can apply at the national level of liberation movement politics as well as in particular cases in parinships force attack. ticular townships. For instance, the UDF leadership came out of hiding towards the end of 1986 to launch a 'Christmas Against the Emergency Campaign, This campaign involved a boycott of white shops. The Commercial, Catering and Allied Workers Union (CCAWUSA), COSATU's shopworkers' union and one of the federation's most militant components was then placed in a very dif ficult position. Should it support a form of action that may endanger its members' jobs and union organisation, when the union had not been consulted, or should it put itself in conflict with the UDF, which is the largest force in the popular movement?
Mandates
These problems emerge in a large part because of the commandist and elitist styles of leadership dominant in certain sections of the liberation movement.
Implied by all of this is the need for democratic and accountable structures of struggle inside the townships.
This aim was pursued by militants from the Metal and Allied Workers Union (MAWU) when with others they tried to build a democratic and accountable organisation in Alexandra township, the Alexandra Action Committee.
Alexandra has been one of the storm centres of working class resistance in South Africa.
In February 1986 the 'six day war* left 27 dead and hundreds injured as a result of the actions of the security forces. Union activists and AAC members have been attacked by plain clothes policemen and vigilantes and have had their homes petrol-bombed and burnt out.
Moses Mayekiso, the general secretary of MAWU, who has been in detention since June last year and faces treason charges arising out of his role in AAC explained the aims of the Action Committee in this interview with South African Metal Worker:
"People were disorganised in Alexandra and they wanted to be united. There were meetings little meetings — of residents discussing how to organise Alexandra. At the end of the day we held meetings street by street trying to hear how people wanted to organise Alexandra. People decided that they should form yard, block and street committees leading up to the Alexandra Action Committee.
Most of these people were workers so the structures were based along the lines of trade union structures — accountability, elections every year and so on.
The function of the Alexandra Action Committee is to coordinate the affairs of the township and to deal with the political and social problems. For example, we have begun to deal with the problem of unemployment. We are planning to have unemployed cooperatives in each and every street, so that everyone who is not working will be doing something for the community. We are also looking at the child-care structures, transport problems, cooperative buying and a tirst aid system - maybe in each street there will be one person who will learn first aid.
There are little courts and central courts. Each yard has a committee which deals with its own problems. If that committee can't solve the pro'blem it is taken to the block committee. If it cannot be solved there it is taken to the street committee and then to the Action Committee. All those committees are acting as courts. People at the central court are delegated to receive complaints and to mediate. We are not really acting in the same manner as the present courts. We would like to get people to come together and discuss their problems.
Problems
—In Alexandra, the question of sentencing is problematic, because how do you sentence a person? We do not believe in corporal punishment, but we have been lucky because people listen to whatever decision is made there. If the person listens then we don't need to implement any punishment. We have been discussing punishment for the person who does not listen, but we haven't reached a solution. However, the 'necklace' will never be used because we believe that the courts have an educational function. They are there to politicise the offender. Most crime in the area is caused by the capitalist and apartheid systems, so we tell the offender that he mustn't allow himself to be used by them."
The EAWTU echoed Moses' last point in a statement on the 'Stop the Killings Campaign'. The union said: 'Our-sense of justice must be higher than that of our oppressors."
WOMAN'S One filthy wet day I was standing in a long bus queue, but was fortunate to be near enough the front to be under the shelter. Most of the people after me had to be content with getting soaked to the skin.
An Asian woman came along with a baby in a push chair and, instead of joining the end of the line, she walked past it and put her child under the shelter in the dry.
The woman next to me turned to look at me with raised eyebrows and a tut. I knew, from many experiences of such collusion amongst white people, that she would not have done this had it been a white woman who had jumped the queue. Her implication was that "these people" have no manners.
Every single white person reading this article will know what I mean and will have experienced such a situation on many, many occasions. It is a kind of hidden language that goes on amongst white people who are stupid enough to assume that the black people it is directed at don't see it, feel it, or know it is there: a nod, a wink, a tut, a shake of the head - a cowardly unspoken way of drawing "us" together in the safety of the crowd against *them"
Racism goes far far deeper than the attacks on the streets, the firebombs through letter boxes, the exclusion from jobs and houses. These actions are in the open. They can be fought. Black people can organise against them. But how do you join together to combat the tut; the weary look to the heavens; the hidden insidious body language and mental attitudes of practically every single white person who passes you in the street?
The majority of white racist Britain are not attackers firebombers. They are people who have been brought up to assume that they are naturally superior because they have white skin - fed on racist history, racist language, brought up on a diet of narrow mindedness and ignorance. They are people who, since racism has become an outspoken issue, feel compelled to say, "l am not a racist but... " and then go on to behave in the same arrogant, ignorant, supremacist way as before It is just as important to fight this aspect of racism as it is the overt discrimination, violence and immigration controls. It is not just a legal or economic battle. It is an ideological battle too. And it must be confronted wherever it raises its ugly head, however small the occasion.
White non-racists, when meeting this attempt at tacit collusion must break the circle, refuse to take part. There is nothing like the spoken language for bringing things out into the open; something which the "I'm not a racist but..." people among us fear.
When asked in a very loud voice so that everyone could hear what the woman in the bus queue was tutting at, she looked startled and embarrass ed and denied any knowledge of communication between us. The wink and the tut had taken no more than a second. But her confusion and discomfort lasted the length of the wait in the queue and her entire bus journey. (I made a point of sitting next to her and asked her, again in a loud voice, if she had any objection to a women keeping her baby dry). I'm not sure she'll do that again, though she may have difficulty in telling anyone what happened or in explaining to herself her own discomfort. At least she cannot assume that all white people feel the way she does and may therefore have to question the way she herself feels.
Scan page 6
On the picket line at Gipsy Hill, South London. Photo lan AND Socialist Organiser talked to Ray Moon, chair, Tunbridge Wells NCU branch:
Tunbridge Wells is 100%, it is amazing. The strike is absolutely solid here.
Initially, it was a response from the rank and file to people being suspended. Now, after two weeks, they are not prepared to go back without a settlement. They have gone too far. They now definitely see it as a battle for trade union rights.
The national executive and Golding have been pushed down the road of the dispute by the rank and file, and not just by what many have seen as the most militant areas, like the London branches.
We are organising the strike through a strike committee, made up of branch officers and representatives, meeting regularly. Then every week there is a mass meeting. At the last one we had over 750 members, out of a branch of 840-850.
Overall, there are 22 scabs but we have also had 29 new members joining since the beginning of the dispute.
The key is the picket line. That is where the members receive information, hear the arguments and feel the solidarity and collective strength.
We have established a branch hardship fund, which already has £2500. Most of this has been raised from our own membership. We have also started to approach the Trades Council and the local Labour Parties for support and collections. Already, we are using the Labour Party office, as a strike headquarters and that has been invaluable.
In Tunbridge Wells the three-day clerical strike last week was not very well supported, with only a minority out. They were suspended on Friday. If they came out solidly with us that would be a real boost, and would cripple BT from both sides of the fence.
Amongst the STE there are a few sympathetic members who give us moral, verbal and financial support. But I do not think there is any chance of getting them all out.
They are not really a union. They represent management grades, and they have been the ones doing BT's dirty work. It was STE members here who picked the names out of the hat and issued the suspension notices.
Whatever BT's propaganda we know the strike is having an effect on the network, both domestic and commercial. In Tunbridge Wells System X has still to be introduced and that, together with the severe weather in South East England, has helped the strike.
The action is also having an effect on the members, and it has raised the consciousness a lot.
Before the strike many did not believe what I and others were saying about what was happening during the miners' strike. But now, when they know the union here is operating a free, 24 hour life and death emergency cover and they see BTmanagement coming on the TV and claiming they are running it, they begin to ask questions.
One difference from the miners' strike is that we are virtually 100% solid, and we have not got a Nottinghamshire eating away at us.
In the past it has been rural areas like Tunbridge Wells that have been the main support of the right wing in the union. I am sure that a majority of members here voted for Golding in the ballot for general secretary last year. But in this dispute Tunbridge Wells was out a day before London and already there is a tremendous amount of criticism at Golding's ralft the beginning of the dispute if was clear that management did not expect the reaction they got all down the line. They saw Golding's election and the right wing executive and they thought they could get away with suspensions Already they • have started to move. Originally they said they would not talk unless we called off the action first, but there are talks going on now.
I am suspicious of what the leadership is up to. I did not like it when I heard them talking about 'winning, losing or drawing'. We are not out to lose or draw. We can win this strike. The membership are not contemplating losing. What worries me is thạt Golding will sell us short.
John TELECOM bosses and leaders of the National Communications Union (NCU) have been holding secret 'informal' talks since the weekend.
Only two things are known for certain about these talks. First, that the 110,000 NCU strikers are as much in the dark about them as anyone else. And second, that the NCU leaders would like to concede the bosses' demand for 'strings' on their pay offer.
One leak from the talks said that ine NCU leaders were going to campaign among the members for a yes vote on a new productivity package. Another hinted at a two-year pay deal, with the strings attached to the 1987 pay increase and not the 1986 one.
NCU general secretary John Golding and other right-wing leaders have always said that they will negotiate on strings. But to accept strings would be a wretched sell-out.
The strike is virtually 100 per cent, and the strings are central to it. For the Telecom bosses, they are the rope to hang the NCU.
British Telecom want to win all their demands, now. The NCU leaders dare not agree to that at this stage. But BT can be shifted.
They were visibly taken aback by the workers' response to the suspensions. They said that they would not talk to the NCU until the strike was called off, but now they have seen the strength of the strike and they're talking. All that keeps the bosses confident is the attitude of the NCU leaders.
Throughout the country, strikers feel that they can win. They are strengthening the picket lines, keepSwindale. home! • Picket out the management union, the STE. They are the main strikebreakers, and there is evidence that many STE members do not like it. The City of London STE branch is said to have asked their executive to instruct all members not to cross picket lines. • Link up with the clerical workers. The clerical workers struck for three days last week, with a 60 percent turnout, but now their leaders have disappeared into separate talks with Telecom management. This division suits the bosses, who in most areas have not suspended thé clerical strikers.
Clerical
visited urgently.
The best structure to do all an elected strike committee. • Maintain 'life and limb' emergency cover, under union control.
The longer the dispute and the greater the management obstruction, the more likely that members' frustration will focus on the emergency cover. Withdrawing that cover will seem a way to strengthen the strike.
But the fact of working-class people suffering will be used by the media with all their power to isolate the strikers. Scabbing will seem to be justified by human need. This can divide and weaken the strike. • Stop the strike-breaking. Take over the exchanges.
British Telecom management are
----- pull-quotes -----
townships and at 'necklacing".
had served a long prison sentence on
The circle of racism