Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Why 'Perdition' is a racist play

Socialist Organiser no. 301, 5 February 1987 · scan p. 4 · about 1,332 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

March on Pentonville Prison to free students. Photo: Andrew Wiarc SHN ists g Your editorial (SO 300), condemtion" raises several important questions for those socialists, such as SO, who are involved in opposing anti-semitism.

The play was staged with the intention of making a political point and it is this - rather than artistic merit -that caused such resistance to it being banned. This was admitted by many involved in the production, with Jim Allen actually affirming the former point.

You are at pains to stress that Allen has a long involvement in Trotskyist and anti-racist organisations and is not an anti-semite. This may well be the case but it does not escape from the truth that the play embraces some of the strands so inherent in classical anti-semitic ideology.

"Collective guilt" is an antisemitic theme running through a play which is full of gross historical distoram indeed the ex-student visitor' mentioned in Polly Vittorini's press release. But I moved not that Campaign Student change its policy on the Middle East, but merely that it ditch support for a democratic secular state in Palestine as a criterion for backing NOLS candidates.

That provision made the criteria too stringent. If applied to NEC elections, it would preclude support for Benn, Heffer and Richardson and many others. I believe that, whether they consciously realise it or not, Campaign Student's motive behind promoting support for a democratic secular state as a condition for support was to split the Left.

The non-socialist side of the Labour Party never has any trouble presenting a united front and thereby giving an appearance of competence. As an illustration: many of the Right disagree passionately over Britain's membership of the EEC. This never means separate slates.

The same unity, motivated by the same overwhelming priority being to defeat the Left, manifests itself in the politics of the careerists in NOLS. I believe that the Left should be similarly single-minded.

All the more so given that the Sawyer proposals' to reorganise the Party's youth section aim to give Labour students a substantial say in Belinda Weaver's review of Tom Stoppard's "Squaring the Circle' was unfair.

Of course, Stoppard's ideological motives were right-wing. But in dealing with the realities of Eastern European societies, 'right wing' opinion often simply tells the truth: that these societies are horrendously undemocratic, bureaucratically (and so incompetently) ruled - and less "free' in the liberal sense than Western European societies.

And Stoppard's stylised and stagey account did, essentially, tell this truth. Belinda's criticism that it sounded like a Daily Mail editorial therefore misses the mark. For sure Stoppard is no expert on Poland, but within the limits of his knowledge, his narrative was honest.

The character of Kuron, for example, was honestly portrayed as a former revolutionary Marxist, committed (whatever he may think nowadays) to a democratic, socialist Poland.

While Belinda may be right to say cions and endless lies. It is claimed that Zionists sent Jews, or allowed them to be sent, to the gas chambers as a way of furthering their ambition to establish a Jewish homeland in Palestine. This is not simply a delegitimisation of Zionism; furthermore, by implication, it offloads some of the responsibility for the Holocaust into the hands of Zionists (and, by implication, the vast majority of the Jewish people.

Right

Holocaust revisionism was an evil previously confined to the gutters of the fascist right until Lenni Brenner imported such ideas into (part of the left's thinking. This play goes further than Brenner; accusations of Zionist unwillingness to resist and complicity in the Nazis' heinous crimes abound; Zionist-Nazi equations are made, such as with the sick idea that blood and soil" was a Zionist, as I well as Nazi, slogan. electing the youth representative on the NEC.

Neither Campaign Student nor SSiN are blameless for the current disarray. Campaign Student have put an astonishing emphasis on the Palestine issue, for all its importance in NUS terms, and Polly's vote for an LCC candidate in recent elections is beyond comprehension.

SSiN should not have got Socialist Organiser to veto a Labour Left Liaison rally taking place at NOLS conference because the Women's Action Committee refused to have SSiN on the platform, nor should they run count of conflicts within Solidarnose is accurate. Walesa is seen as a "moderate' with more militant (and right wing? — Stoppard doesn't suggest so) opponents.

The circle that Stoppard says can't be squared is 'the idea of freedom as it is understood in the West and the idea of socialism as it is understood in the Soviet empire. Now, of course, this statement is ideologically loaded in that it implies that the 'West' is actually 'free' But you don't have to be a Cold Warrior to think that even so it is an idea with a germ of truth in it. Even the limited democratic rights we possess in Britain are incompatible with the systems in Eastern Europe, as Solidarnose found out. It is impossible for a mass democratic workers movement to coexist with the Stalinist bureaucracies.

Stoppard therefore tells the essential truth despite his ideological starting point.

You may not like the artistic style (personally, didn't much), but that's a different issue.

EDWARD Such holocaust revisionism minimalises the significance of the event which serves as the greatest indictment of the evils of fascism and This is something that all those involved in the struggle against racism should be fundamentally opposed to. Further, it seeks to marginalise the Jewish experience, adding nothing but grist to the mills of anti-semites in this country, both on the right and the left.

As socialists, we should be in support of those denying a platform to racist ideas. Jim Allen may not be an overt, nor organised, anti-semite, but many of the ideas developed in "Perdition" most certainly are antisemitic. Now that SO has recognised much of modern day "anti-Zionism"" for what it really is, our response to it should be the same to that which is applied to other forms of racism.

Yours fraternally, GERRY ALLEN Reading iL. T. candidates against the Black Sections candidates.

Ideally, I would like to see a NOLS slate consisting of the Pollys and Kingsleys of this world, as well as the Michele Carlisles and Jane Ashworths. A slate prepared to unite on the issues where there is agreement (which, although Socialist Action and Socialist Organiser will hate to admit it, is the vast majority of issues), and tolerate each other's differences (and the right to campaign on these differences) where there is dissent. But the acrimony and vitriol of recent meetings show that this is utopian.

Throughout the last nine months 1 have tried to promote the cause of Left unity in Labour's youth and student sections, only to have my hopes shattered by first one Trotskyist sect, then the other. Is this what the great man really wanted? I am resigned to the fact that arguing the case for a united Left in this context is in reality a matter of trying to reason with preprogrammed robots, DANNY NICOL Jane Ashworth comments:

Dear Danny, You say we would "never admit" that there is agreement between Socialist Organiser and Socialist Action on "the vast majority of issues".

But in my article last week I too expressed the opinion that the only plank in Campaign Student's platform which divides it fundamentally from SO students (and from most of SSiN which is much broader than SO) is the question of Israel and the Palestinian Arabs — the issue you accuse Socialist Action of artificially overemphasising for the purpose of splitting the student left.

SSiN is broad enough - and democratic enough - to accommodate Campaign Student. Socialist Action's ultra-factional Campaign Student isn't big enough, or broad enough, or democratic enough to accommodate SSiN. That's the problem.

----- pull-quotes -----

ning the Royal Court's decision to ban Jim Allen's play "Perdi-

that the masses' don't get much of a voice in Squaring the Circle', the ac-

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 301

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →