Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Debating Ireland

Socialist Organiser no. 301, 5 February 1987 · scan pp. 3–4 · about 786 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

"Our proposal for a federal united Ireland is not advice to the British government or the United Nations. It is part of a transitional programme for Ireland, a programme to unite the Irish working class", argued Socialist Organiser editor John O'Mahony at a debate in London last Friday, 30th.

"The key problem in Ireland", he said, "is the existence of an Irish minority with a distinct national identity - the one million Protestants. British interference has worsened and complicated this problem, but British withdrawal now, on its own, would not resolve it.

*It would lead not to Irish national self-determination but to an attempt THE DEBATE ONMIRELAIND ween views on the left. What son or unrea treland could win tne support or the Fro testant workers? What way to working class unity?

Workers' Liberty no. 5 LIS availabte, price E1 plus 18m postage, from PO Box 823, London SE15AY of Irelan at "self-determination' by the Protestants and bloody civil war. The Catholics could not defeat the Protestants in that civil war, even if it were desirable.

**To achieve a socialist or a democratic solution in Ireland we need a united working class. And for that we need a programme of consistent democracy, on the bass of which both Catholic and Protestant workers can honestly assure each other that they have no wish to oppress or subjugate the other community"

Keith Hassell of Workers' Power saw things differently. SO, he said, is telling an untruth when it claims to support the oppressed Northern Ireland Catholics, because it makes concessions to the Protestants.

And those concessions will not work. Keith Hassell interpreted SO's proposals for local autonomy for the Protestant areas as necessarily meaning a bourgeois federal Ireland. instead of that, he said, we need some communist propaganda directed at the Protestant workers.

Those workers must be "confronted with the awesome might" of the anti-Unionist working class, and forced to give up their privileges for the sake of class unity. Only after that can any sort of federalism be useful.

A further point of difference for Workers' Power was the evaluation of Southern Ireland. John O'Mahony had argued that Southern Ireland, with its refusal to support Britain in World War 2 or to join NATO, and its autonomous role in the EEC, is not a semi-colony but an independent capitalist state.

Keith Hassell insisted that Southern Ireland is a semi-colony, "prevented from any form of independent national development". It may be that British investment no longer dominates, but Ireland's big colony dominated by a coalition of foreign debt still delines it as a semiimperialist powers' The British Army in the North is potentially a force to intervene against Southern workers, and so the national struggle against Britain is central throughout Ireland.

Gerry Downing of the Workers' Revolutionary Party was the third speaker in the debate. He explained that his group is rethinking its ideas. Its predecessor, the SLL, distorted reality by talking about revolutionary Catholic/Protestant workers' unity as an accomplished fact in Northern Ireland and demanding a 'workers" and peasants' government at Stormont' Much has to be rethought. But the basic principle is to support the Irish national struggle. A civil war is unfortunately probable, but there is no way round that. So Gerry Downing agreed more with Workers' Power than with Socialist Organiser, Speakers from the floor included representatives of the Revolutionary Communist Party and the Spartacist League. Well over 100 people attended the debate, which was one of a series being held around the country. It is the first time since the early 1970s that Ireland has been debated much on the British left.

The Labour Party should wage a massive campaign against the Tory attack on democratic rights. But unfortunately Neil Kinnock has been far less outspoken on the subject than the leaders of the Alliance!

When the Zircon affair first surfaced, Kinnock criticised the government...for failing to suppress the New Statesman report efficiently enough!

The BBC should show its Secret Society' series. And we also need a campaign to get rid of the Special Branch and the Official Secrets Act.

Project Zircon should be scrapped and the money spent instead on hospitals or housing.

Spoialist Orgamiser PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA.

ПР630 7966 Latestdate for reumne-finct post Monday TiDy Pho Monday evening.

Editor: John O'Mahony. Typesetting: Upstream Ltd (TU).

Published by Socialist Organiser, PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA.

Canted byreet Ence Olicer (TU), London E2.

Registered as a newspaper at the Post Office.

Signed articles do not necessarily reflect the views of SocialistiOrganiser.

February 1987 page 3

Scan page 4

TERS

----- pull-quotes -----

Workers' January reports.

Organiser debated issue d with Workers' Power and Press (WRP) on Friday 30 London. Martin Thomas

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 301

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →