Campaign Student: broad forum or narrow group?
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-01-29Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
Students at Wapping. Photo: lan Swindale ALIST ACTION'S PRESS RELEASE WE PRINT this press statement, produced by Socialist Action and distributed at the Labour Left Liaison meeting last Monday, 26 January, for the enlightenment of SO readers.
Like Socialist Action's entire Campaign Student' project, it suffers from a central contradiction which reduces it to nonsense. Either 'Campaign Studen!" is a narrow SA factional grouping (which is what it is), or it is a broad grouping (as it tries to present itself. And if it is a broad group, then it cannot claim the right to function as a tight, exclusive. closed-in SA faction.
It is either-or. They must choose one or the other.
'Campaign Student" presents itself as a broad left-wing student movement, the student wing of the loose association at the head of which stands the Campaign Group of MPs. The statement says that the aims of 'Campaign Student' "are to help link students with the Alliance for Socialism which Campaign Forum is building in the wider labour movement"
But the Campaign Group of MPs and the local Campaign Groups are not a tightly-organised or precisely-defined political entity of the sort SA wants 'Campaign Student' to be.
And the fact is that 'Campaign Student' has nothing to do with the Campaign Group of MPs, which has told them to stop using its logo and to stop pretending to be what they are not. "Campaign Student" is a get-rich-quick enterprise of Socialist Action, attempting to purloin the Campaign Group label and franchise in the student field.
Its purpose is to group students around SA, attracting them by the name of the Campaign Group.
This requires that they must try to exclude undesirables such as SO supporters - and this is especially urgent because there are so very few SA students.
To exclude undesirables - ie. SO - SA saddled 'Campaign Student' right from the start with a full set of 'principles', comprehensive enough for a rather tight political party. No dissent on any of the points is possible. More than that: as can be seen from the press statement, no disagreement on interpretation of the principles is possible.
Who will decide? The SA "founders' will decide! Even when they are in a minority at the meeting they have called.
For example: SO supports the right of black people to organise, so we agree with the principle they enunciate. But it is also demanded that we accept SA's interpretation, that this means automatic support for whatever the existing Black Section nucleus decides.
Even so, on the level of principle their dight Socialist Action platform does not make 'Campaign Student' "a clear alternative to other currents in NOLS and Exclude For example, only on the question of Israel is there a fundamental difference with SO. (And since we are talking about the self-appointed student wing of the Campaign Group, it should be said that it is unlikely that all or even most of the Campaign Group of MPs would back Socialist Action's demand for the complete destruction and elimination of the Jewish state!)
From all this you get the nonsense of a 'broad' so-called •Campaign Student' run by SA as a narrow, tightly-controlled and policed factional enterprise, essentially aimed against Socialist Students in NOLS (SSiN).
Where SSiN allows a variety of opinions, 'Campaign Student" allows only the rigid SA 'party line' Where SSiN has open meetings and conferences (and Polly Vittorini of SA attended the last one), *Campaign Student' wants to close itself off.
But if they call a conference in the guise of the student wing of the Campaign Group, they do not have the right to close themsclves off so that they can safely function as an SA faction!
Nor the right to arbitrarily impose 'conditions' and an unchallengeable 'platform' worked out by the SA caucus. The broad "Campaign Student' meeting must - like SSiN gatherings - have the right to decide on the platform and to decide to change it.
That is how the labour movement operates. That is democracy. The alternative to it is tight factional autocracy dressed up as a broad campaign, When the 'Campaign Student" meeting closed and SA - together with some supporters - went away to have an admitted SA caucus, nobody dreamed of interfering with them, or "intimidating, disrupting or wrecking" their caucus, which they had every right to hold in as much privacy as they liked.
But the private caucus was as bizarre as the aborted Campaign Student' meeting. Ms Vittorini, leader of the half-dozen SA people present, shouted at the argumentative sympathisers that if they didn't like her way of doing things they could 'f... off". One non-SA participant afterwards ruefully reflected that SA was more Stalinist' than SSiN, where your right to disagree and dissent and decide by voting was taken for granted.
The rest of the open letter is just hysteria and lies, which nevertheless need to be nailed in detail.
Polly Vittorini declares that the Campaign Student' meeting on 30 November had decided that SSiN supporters could not participate in "Campaign Student' Robin Laney, a member of the Campaign for Labour Party Democracy (CLPD) and one of the three ad-hoc officers of "Campaign Student', said that this never happened, and that if it were to be forced through then he would resign.
The meeting was not broken up'. SA were in a minority at the broad meeting they called, and spent the time trying te work our political reasons for excluding the majority of the meeting from participation.
It was, they said, *their meeting'. The majority of the meeting could not scrap 'their" proposals or conditions at their meeting.
The recent ex-student visitor who wanted a different policy on Israel was Danny Nicol, neither an SO nor a SSiN supporter but a CLPD executive member (and, in fact, part of the initiating Campaign Student' group; the small group of CLPD students sup ported the setting up of Campaign Student').
What forced' the meeting to close (in fact the chair, Kingsley Abrams, ruled that it had never properly been convened)? It was. the autocratic minority, faced with a meeting that was not 'theirs".
'Campaign Student' was "prevented" from 'adopting criteria
----- pull-quotes -----
STUDEN 1al
Cily, at london Polstechnic Student Union FICHTING FOR FUTURE