[Socialist Organiser nọ 300.29 January 1987 page 9…]
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-01-29Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
Socialist Organiser nọ 300.29 January 1987 page 9 TOM STOPPARD'S play Squaring the Circle' had the same tone as the 'Let Poland be Poland' extravaganza, in which "democrats' like Reagan shed crocodile tears about workers' rights in Poland. Reagan and Thatcher are happy to use Solidarity, the trade union outlawed by the Polish Government, as a stick to beat Poland with, all the while attacking their own working classes at home.
I wonder how Reagan would feel if confronted by a trade union leader with 10 million workers behind him, all clamouring for change. Or whether Thatcher would welcome a Catholic Archbishop's lecture on workers' rights. I certainly can't see Stoppard penning a new play about GCHQ, Patco or Wapping.
Stoppard uses real personages into whose mouths he puts a lot of fatalistic, ponderous speechifying. In fact, none of the characters talk -they declaim. Lech Walesa's I made a decision - it takes guts to make a decision' was probably the nadir of Stoppard's dialogue. And Stoppard freely reinvents real people so that, half the time, they express his ideas rather than their own. -For example, a secret meeting is shown between Lech Walesa, Archbishop Glemp of the Polish Catholic Church, and General Jaruzelski. After a bit of speechifying, the narrator figure is careful to tell us that this particular scene is pure conjecture, as no one knows what was really said. But Stoppard has put his ideas across. The disclaimer is about as useful as a judge telling a jury to disregard what they just heard.
The narrator is a curious figure, half off-stage - an American offering a detached and cynical commentary on events. His role is structured to allow the play to be generally proSolidarity without letting people identify too closely with the working class activists.
Solidarity's militants are not the heroes of this play. They're only raw material for the narrator's comThere's no business like show Illegal Solidarnosc demonstration ments.
Stoppard puts stern-jawed, tellingthese-commies-where-to-get-off speech in the mouth of a Catholic Archbishop, who firmly declares he is on the side of workers' rights. The fact that the Catholic Church in Poland accommodates to the regime, and has tried to suppress worker militancy, is ignored.
Lies Stoppard's central indictment of Poland's rulers is that they tell lies, that they can't be trusted. He is much less concerned about their making workers live in poverty, deprived of rights.
The play is phoney, because Stoppard's sympathies aren't with Solidarity's struggle. It's just an excuse for a cold war outing, an attempt to show socialism as inherently wicked. When the Polish bureaucrats talk about a party strictly organised from the top down, they invoke Lenin's name. But that was Stalin's idea, not Lenin's. When another says, *The Party must take the leading role - that's communism!? that is another Stalinist distortion. Stoppard attacks the Polish Stalinists as if they were Lenin's direct descendants, as it Poland today is what Leninism inevitably leads to, rather than a grotesque parody.
Genuine socialism, as seen by Lenin and Trotsky, was for workers" control over production and distribution through the workers' own organisations. The Party had to win leadership of the working class -such a leading role could not be taken for granted, or worse, enforced.
Many in Solidarity were hoping to achieve that kind of self-organisation. Others like Walesa and Jacek Kuron, believed that to take on Osc the state machine head on would be a recipe for disaster. They promoted the idea of a "self-limiting revolution' — where they would work within the constraints of existing stuctures but hollow them out from within. But the movement couldn't be limited - it came up against the state time after time. The question of 'who rules?' was posed.
Solidarity was a movement in ferment, with many different strands. No sense of this can be gained from this play. The movement is invisible. One doesn't get a sense of people struggling to come to grips with events as they unfolded - there are no uncertainties, just speechmaking, and attitude striking.
The narrator observes that, in provate, Party officials probably don't talk like the Pravda editorials. Stoppard talks like a Daily Mail one.
Tom Stoppard's *Squaring the Circle' Channel 4, last Thursday, 9.30pm.
THE ALMIGHTY moves in mysterious ways His wonders to perform. Like when He spoke to James Anderton on the motorway.
The hirsute Chief Constable was on his way to make a speech about AIDS when it happened. As he later explained on Radio 4's religious programme, "Something was speaking to me inside and the words that I was using in my speech just flooded into my mind. I couldn't change them... I had to say what I was compelled to say"
What he actually said, you may remember, was that AIDS is a sort of punishment visited upon us by God and spread about by homosexuals, prostitutes and drug addicts, "swirling about in a cesspool of their own making"
He said plenty more when questioned on the radio. I missed the programme (which goes out at 8am on Sundays) but the Daily Mail carried a detailed account: *Police Chief James Anderton said yesterday that he believed God had chosen him to be a prophet, "And he admitted he used his job as an instrument of God's judgment' . Mr Anderton, Chief Constable of Greater Manchester, was asked... if he regarded himself as an Old Testament prophet or as a modern equivalent of John the Baptist.
"He replied, I smile because don't actually suggest it myself. It's very great compliment".
By Jim Denham Do you remember back in 1984 when Tony Benn stood in the Chesterfield by-election. The Sun, on the day of the election, carried a story on the subject of Benn's mental health entitled "Benn on the Couch — A Top Psychiatrist's View of Britain's Leading Lefty"
In 1981 the Daily Mail did a similar job on Ken Livingstone on the basis of telephone calls to three psychiatrists. No prizes for guessing what conclusions the Sun and the Mail came to in each case — although the shrinks themselves later claimed to have been misquoted.
James Anderton, though, need have no fear of a visit from the men in white coats, to judge by the tabloids' reactions to his latest 'controversial' comments, The Mail's report (headlined, I'm an instrument of God, says Anderton') was admirably factual, unsensanonal, and entirely devoid of psychological analysis.
Thursday's Sun (which 1 did not buy, incidentally) devoted an entire page to defending the Chief Constable, under the headline, "He Speaks No Evil' The piece was written in an appropriately evangelical style. "There IS evil in our society. It is the source of everything that is wrong in our lives. It can never be combatted merely by physical measures.
The struggle demands the force and the strength of religious conviction. It demands that people should be encouraged by word and example to live by moral standards.
*There have been suggestions that James Anderton is mad. The same charge could just as easily have been brought against Jesus Christ when He came to earth"
This stirring defence seems particularly poignant when one remembers that upon being appointed Chief Constable of Greater Manchester in 1976, Anderton's first act was to launch a vigorous crusade against pornography. His special squads raided over 200 bookshops, newsagents and warehouses.
Their seizures included the Sun Page Three Girl Annual.