A socialist critique of Israel
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-01-29Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
TECHNO Without the spur of the market, innovation would stop. We might be spared some dreck, but our high streets would be reduced to the drabness of Moscow. Or so the Tory/SDP argument runs.
In fact, according to a new survey by US management consultants, new products are "pushed along initially by technology, and not pulled by the market. The curiosity of an individual rescarcher is more compelling than any clamouring demand from the marketplace.
Such things as the Sony Walkman, the computerised body scanner, and the anti-ulcer drug Tagamet were pushed into produclion only by obstinate rescarchers, against the resistance of l0p managers.
A socialist planned economy, giving grealer scope for research, would increase innovation. The problem in the USSR is not "planning" but burcaucracy PERHAPS the clearest way to reply to John O'Mahony's comments (Letters, SO 295) is to explain briefly my overall views.
Much of what passes as antiZionism' is implicitly, and sometimes explicitly, anti-semitic. The nicesounding programme of a secular, democratic state' is a utopia, and in fact could only be implemented by unrealisable except by military conquest of Israel.
If it is supposed to be voluntary on the Jews' part, it is not an answer to the national question. A long (who could know how long?) process of change of heart by the Jews is not much of a programme for Palestinians facing oppression now Withdrawal of Israeli forces from the post-1967 occupied territories, combined with the right of secession of majority Arab areas within pre-67 Israel, is a big part of an immediate democratic programme.
So, I support Israel's right to exist. I agree with John O'Mahony that this is an unconditional right - that is, it is ridiculous to say that we support the col as Isra •pletely Israel.
quest of Israel until such time I is a nicer place. I am comopposed to the conquest of Chauvinism John O'Mahony says that we should champion the rights of the Palestinians, and support Jews fighting Jewish chauvinism. On what basis, though? What does opposition to Jewish chauvinism mean?
It seems to me that it must include trenchant criticism of the refusal of Jews to countenance a large influx of Arabs into their state. We should not advocate return' on the point of a chauvinist's gun, nor deny the Jews rights until they agree to allow Arabs in. The agency for opposition to the racist, exclusivist character of Israel, and therefore for change, is the working class in Israel.
But Israel is exclusivist, and we do have a socialist responsibility to oppose this exclusivism. Israel's right to exist is not conditional upon it ceasing to be exclusivist, but opposition to its exclusivism should be part of our programme.
Israel's definition as a state for Jews rather than its citizens, which O'Mahony sees no problem with, 15 an expression of this exclusivism. It is part of the institutional structure that denies Arabs rights within Israel Because of this, I think it is wrong to identify ourselves with "Zionists' even as a quiet way to make a stand against the hysterical 'anti-Zionists' The Zionist Movement - though not, of course, all individual Zionists — are our political enemies too, I think it is possible both to make a stand against anti-semitism on the left and to maintain a socialist critique of the Israeli state.
CLIVE BRADLEY, West London.
Send letters to Socialist Organiser, PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA. Please try to keep your letters below 300 words, or we may have to cut them for reasons of space.
Scan page 5
ORGANISER