Why the Royal Court was wrong to cancel 'Perdition
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-01-29Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 3
Socialist Organiser no 300 29 January 1987 page model for the Labour Party leader Hugh Gaitskell at the beginning of the '60s. The aim was the freeing of the Labour Party from too much.
working-class influence, and from any notion of a socialism understood to mean the replacement of the existing system and the achievement of the common ownership of the means.
of production.
Now the German voters have given the answer to Kinnock's line. They have rejected Rau at the polls, despite the terrible record of West Germany's ruling Christian Democrats.
Wants PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA. 01-639 7965 Latest date for reports: first post Monday or by phone, Monday evening.
Editor: John O'Mahony. Typesetting: Upstream Ltd (TU).
Published by Socialist H2B.
London SE15 4NA.
Endou sE (TU), London E2.
Registered as a newspaper at the Post Office.
domok lectathe vievm rganiser.. UNDER pressure of a powerful outery, the Royal Court Theatre has decided to abandon its production of Jim Allen's anti-Zionist play 'Perdition' , a couple of days before it was due to open.
We have not read - nor, of course, seen — Allen's play. It is, we understand, an attempt to blame the Zionist movement for the passivity with which the vast majority of Hungarian Jews submitted to their own deportation to the Nazi death camps.
That the big majority of the Hungarian Jews did submit in this fashion is a matter of history, testified to by many academic and non-polemical studies.
What role, if any, did Zionists play in this? This is an important question. Similar questions arise in the history of other peoples.
How, for example, did it happen that about a million people in Ireland let themselves starve to death in 1845-8 without anything remotely 222422223 like an uprising?
The basic reason for the passivity of the Hungarian Jews is probably linked to the class structure of their society. The Polish Jews, too, at first submitted passively, and organised their own segregation and deportation: Jewish police were in charge of the Warsaw Ghetto. But the last remnants of the Ghetto, after having made concession after concession, finally revolted, magnificently though hopelessly.
The passivity of so many (or, in the Irish case, all) of the victims is one of the most terrible things about the Holocaust, as about the Irish Famine. It can only be a source of pain to think of such things. It is especially painful for the survivors and the relatives of the victims of the Nazi slaughter.
But these issues are difficult to separate from the politics of the Middie East today. If you hate what Israel is doing and has done to the Palestinian Arabs, it is tempting to read a condemnation of "Zionism' back into history:
You can weave the stery of various Jewish, including Zionist, collaborators in what became their own destruction, into an account which puts on the victims part of the blame for the mass murder of the Jews of Europe.
Jim Allen may have done that, or erred in that direction. But Jim Allen is not conceivably an anti-semite He has been a Trotskyist for about 40 years. He joined the movement in 1948-9 He was then a clothing worker in North Manchester, in a predominant ly Jewish district, at a time where the Mosleyite fascists had had a new lease of life, partly thanks to the wave of anti-semitism generated by the Israeli Jewish war with Britain in 1946-8. He would not have come over to the then very puny Trotskyist movement if he had any anti-semitic tendencies, or the inclination to find scapegoats for the things he found intolerable in capitalism.
40 years is a very long time m politics - especially for one who has written some of the best-ever drama about the working class and its conditions and struggles.
If Jim Allen and Ken Loach make and produce such polemical drama, they cannot be surprised if they provoke a violent reaction from those who are outraged and have old wounds opened by it.
It is not a matter of cold historical evaluation, but of controversy which relates both to the terrible events of the recent past and, indirectly, to the current politics of the Middle East.
Nevertheless, the Royal Court Theatre should not have bowed fo the pressure. The play would caudistress. Many things cause distress. The urge to ban and stifle is almost always wrong.
Freedom, said Rosa Luxemburg, Is always for the one who disagrees for the one whose views you find distressing and offensive.