Half truths, fantasy, polemics and inaccuracy
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-01-22Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
Oh the rhetorical polemic of Tony Greenstein (SO, 15 January)...so much huffing and puffing but very little in the way of factual accuracy. Yet another tirade of half-truths, sheer fantasy and what the writer would not doubt claim to be anti-Zionism and nothing more.
Firstly there is the question of Zionism and the Holocaust. In the inimitable style of the new breed of (left wing) Holocaust revisionists, Greenstein attempts to justify his illogical analysis with plain lies.
The truth is that Zionists were at the forefront of the resistance against the Nazis — in the ghettos, concentration camps and towns - and to label the Judenrat and others who did not resist as "Zionists" is crass reactionary stereotyping of the worst order.
Jews did not die in the Holocaust because of so-called "Zionist collaboration" but because of the failure of the working class and indeed the entire world to resist the Nazis. Don't attempt to blame Jews (or Zionists, it's the same thing really) for anti-semitism - that is the sole responsibility of the anti-semites.
True, there was some support offered against the Hitlerite regime l office at 150 Walworth Road. Once fixed, the date cannot be changed without consent. The closing date for registration of delegates is January 30th at 9 am. Also remember that the certain states or people but the fact of the matter remains that these were isolated incidents. The majority actively assisted or passively accepted the attempted genocide of the Jewish people. That is why six million Jews were slaughtered and, as the renowned Marxist intellectual Isaac Deutscher wrote:
*If instead of arguing against Zionism in the 1920s and 1930s, I had urged European Jews to go to Palestine, I might have helped save some of the lives that were later extinguished in Hitler's gas chambers."
Secondly, there is Greenstein's marginalisation and trivialisation of anti-semitism in contemporary society. However, state racism still exists against Jews in countries such as Syria and the USSR.
The truth of the situation is that anti-semitism remains the binding force of international fascism today - it is what links the National Front to Farrakhan and to the neo-Nazi AWB in South Africa. Anti-semitism is still very much at the core of racist and fascist ideology.
It may not be so evident as, say, the oppression of blacks in this contry but to dismiss it as fringe, with it being at the bottom of Greenstein's. league table of oppression is hardly a socialist response.
But if one is to believe Greenstein's analysis then the reason why antisemitism is not like it was 50 years ago is neither due to socialism nor Zionism but to Capitalism. For according to the writer it is the process of bourgeoisification that has reduced anti-semitism to the fringe!
Then again, such a reduction of anti-semitism and intellectual perversion is hardly surprising from someone like Tony Greenstein.
Yours fraternally, STEVE CHANNON Socialist Students NOLS can be contacted at 54a Peckham Rye London SE15.
----- pull-quotes -----
South Africa; STUDENTI RELEASE THE DETAINEES! -25p