Missing the point
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-01-15Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
Socialist Organiser, no.298. 15th January 1987. Page 10. Adam Woolf's ra ther abusive sally into he debare on Zionism misses the poInt.
For example. Adam disputes than jury" pointing 1o what has happened in Africa, Asia and latin America.
Bur it is anything bur "liberalism" to think that World War Two was an imperiali war, and that six million ews died at the hands of rapacious German imperialism and not hindered in this genocidal activity by . he "democratic allies. What happen ed to Jews wasn't just racism' it was an imperials/ racism.
There is nothing racist about thinking thai the programme of the PLO is Arab chauvinist. And John O Mahony obviously does not "legitimate the racist oppression of the Palestinians"
Adam doesn'i seem to have thought about the issues. Smashing the Zionist state' is a very militant and revoluHonary sounding slogan. But if Adam wants to play-aci as a Marxist he should be clear about what social force is to implemenı it. Either he thinks that a united working class will do it, and he equates a secular democratic state with "socialism' - in which case he simply begs the question, and effectively demands that the Palestinians must wait until this united, socialist movemeni has been built. Or he thinks that this united state, the smashing Israel, will be imposed by military force. That would be conquest - there is no other word for it.
1i least have the decency to find out what we are arguing about before denouncing us as "racist'.
CLIVE BRADLEY class in the West, unlike the 1930s.
The Jewish people have changed and with it anti-semitism.
As Abram Leon noted, *Zionism transposes anti-semitism to all of history, it saves itself the trouble of studying the various forms of antisemitism and their evolution." (Jewish Question, p. 247). If Jews today, unlike the Jews of the East End who fought the fascists, base their identity around Israel, then that is a reactionary identity.
Colonial
Zionism as a colonial movement is not something of the past. Internal colonisation has been a continuing feature of Israel's existence. Today's operations on the West Bank are no different to what it did in the Galilee.
O'Mahony asks what is wrong with Israel being a state for all Jews as opposed to all its citizens. The answer is racism, not merely in this or that
Assimilation
The article demolishes other straw targets. Socialists did not advocate assimilation as a strategy, neither do we mourn it. Only incorrigible reactionaries would consciously seek to preserve differences of caste or religion where individuals choose otherwise, Nobody on the Left believes Jews have a 'demonic place' in history. Those of us who are Jewish and whose opposition to Zionism came as a consequence of our revolutionary socialism understand not only Zionism's relationship to antisemitism but also its reactionary role within Jewish politics.
Even the Jewish Socialists Group understand that Israel feeds off the diaspora Jewish communities contributing nothing to their well being.
Instead of an analysis which sees Israel as an artificial state, which cannot exist other than in alliance with they would be irrelevant. Since when has support for a democratic, secular state been part of reactionary Arab chauvinism? It is a demand that is rejected by all the Islamic chauvinists. Unfortunately, Socialist Organiser, in retusing to give any meaningful support to the Palestinians - either in the labour movement or in NUS (where it is to the right of most reformists and on a par with Militant) has accommodated to imperialism.
As for helping the left "scour itself clean" of anti-semitism, this in itself speaks volumes about O'Mahony's analysis of racism — it's not located in society but. in individuals. However not wishing to stand in his way, I suggest an open debate between ourselves and John O'Mahony in which he will have the opportunity to begin scouring.
Yours fraternally, TONY GREENSTEIN, Labour Movement Campaign for Palestine. sentence appears here as writthe original manuscript.
Scan page 11
RGROUND HANGERS
----- pull-quotes -----
the "Jews have been the chief single victim of imperialism in the 201h cen-