Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The original article

Socialist Organiser no. 298, 15 January 1987 · scan pp. 9–10 · about 1,177 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

Jimmy Ross's article but from the English teachers Socialist Organiser no.298. 15th January 1987. Page 9. Despite the overwhelming rejection by Scottish teachers of the latest government offer, the Rifkind Deal, and this Thursday's strike by union members, there is still unease about the outcome of the dispute.

The EIS executive has successfully resisted being tied down by the special conference to a specific claim or programme of industrial action.

A massive escalation of the action is needed. Instead we are getting more of the same selective action as last year.

Many teachers feel that the proposed selective action is an attempt to get a few more crumbs from the government.

It is now surprising to hear that some on the left inside the union are painting the following picture: That the EIS executive is solidly against the Rifkind Deal, the Main Package and any trade off on conditions for wages.

This fantasy has led some on the left (like EIS executive member lan McCalman) to argue that the threat to Scottish teachers comes not from their own trade union bureaucracy, but from the English teachers.

This is dangerous nonsense.

It is just not true that the BIS leadership is solidly against Main or a trade off on conditions and pay. General Secretary John Pollock was at pains to stress that teachers will be "realistic" in negotiations.

Anyone who, for whatever motives, tries to lay the blame for any shoddy future deal at the door of English teachers rather than where it belongs - at the door of our own leadership - is merely giving left cover in advance to a sell out by our own leadership.

The left are more powerful now in the Els bureaucracy than ever before, but the danger is that they are being co-opted as apologists for the official strategy and an official sell out Just last week Pollock praised the disgraceful climbdown by left-led Strathclyde EIS over the action on oversize classes. It shows, he said, HOW made in hegotiptons: That is exactly wade in are worried about.

Scan page 10

is confined to the fringe. When, some 18 months ago, Socialist Organiser began debating its position on Zionism/Palestine, we forecast that SO would move into the Zionist camp.

Moshe Machover of Matzpen, the Socialist Organisation in Israel, was invited to participate in that debate, because he too disagreed with the democratic, secular state position. Were he to read John O'Mahony's article (4 December) he would, 1 am sure, disagree with it in its entirety. Moshe is one of those who struggled to win a previously Zionist left over to an anti-Zionist position. O'Mahony seeks to do the opposite.

By his own admission he is a Zionist supporter and despite all that has been written on the Zionist movement, its colonial roots, its reactionary role in Jewish politics, he has learnt nothing and forgotten all. He has even confused the terms 'Jewish' and "Zionist' and then accused the rest of the Left of anti-semitism for the same sin!

Escape

Zionism never was a method of fighting anti-semitism. It held antisemitism couldn't be fought, far better to come to terms with it and establish their own state. For most Jews it wasn't even a means of escape. Some 2.5 million Jews who did flee went not to Palestine but to Britain and America, Describing those who believed that the Bolshevik Revolution made Zionism irrelevant, Chaim Weizmann, the first President of Israel, wrote "Nothing can be more superficial and nothing can be more wrong than that. The sufferings of Russian Jewry never were the cause of Zionism."* Similar statements were made by Ben Gurion during the Nazi era and the leader of American Zionism, Abba Hillel Silver. Israel was not "conceived as a refuge for all the victims of anti-Semitism" (otherwise it could hardly have seen in antisemitism a force for good that stimulated emigration) but the only means of preserving the Jewish people as a collectivity. It was the response of the Jewish petit-bourgeoisie.

It is beyond doubt that the Zionist movement obstructed the movement to save Jews from the Holocaust, terming it 'refugeeism' • c.g. It opposed the lowering of the immigration movements in Britain and the US arguing that the refugees should go to Palestine. Nor is it true that all methods of fighting anti-semitism in Europe failed.

Not only, by Begin's own admission, did some two million Jews survive by escaping into Russia, degenerated as the revolution was, but opposition to anti-semitism in countries such as Denmark (where the entire Jewish community was smuggled out to Sweden), Bulgaria and Italy did prevent many more Jews being killed. In Holland there was even a general strike against the deportations which the Zionist Judenrat opposed. Whose reading of history is false?

Even today, far from being the "life-raft state' . Israel ieopardises the position of Jews in the diasporai with its genocide of the Palestinians. What was Israel doing when over 2,000 young leftist Jews were being tortured to death in Argentina? Selling arms to the Junta. And the Zionist leaders of that community? Telling others not to make a fuss. Compare that to the Zionist campaign over Soviet Jewry.

Nothing in Trotsky's writings leads one to the conclusion that he supported the Zionist enterprise in Palestine. In July 1940 just before his death he wrote "The attempt to solve the Jewish question through the migration of Jews to Palestine can now be seen for what it is, a tragic mockery. of the Jewish people...Never was it so clear as it is today that the salvation of the Jewish people is bound up inseparably with the overthrow of the capitalist system,"

Personal O'Mahony's obsession with antisemitism blinds him to the fact that anti-semitism today in Europe is not, unlike 50 years ago, state sponsored. It is a personal form of racism, contined to fringe fascist groups. It is black people in Britain, Arab people in France, Turkish workers in Germany who experience state racism. Jewish people have socially moved upwards and politically moved rightwards.

A London cemetery, 1986 That is why we say that antisemitism has been redefined and the term "black anti-semitism' like 'left anti-semitism' is used as a means off countering opposition to Zionism.

Racism is not merely a question of personal prejudice, but at the level of class, a specifically oppressed section of the working class. Apart from France, there is no Jewish working policy but in every single tacet of the State's operations.

It means Israel's Arabs are at best tolerated and at worst unwanted. It means the growth of Kach and Tehiya, it means apartheid and expulsion. It means concern over the 'demographic problem', i.e. too many Arabs. imperialism, O'Mahony resorts to moral relativism. Jews are "the chief single victim of imperialism in the 20th century" "Incomparably less terrible things" were done to the Jews than to the Palestinians.* This ranking of hierarchies is ironically attacked on the facing page by Ms Carlisle and Ashworth.

Even were these statements true

----- pull-quotes -----

DISCUSSIONC AS JEWS

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 298

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →