Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

A use for the Telegraph

Socialist Organiser no. 298, 15 January 1987 · scan p. 9 · about 841 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

Been a bit nippy lately, hasn't it? But if you want something to warm the cockles of your heart this Monday, there was a caring, compassionate Daily Telegraph with a few home truths about the plight of our senior citizens in the winter months:

"As was seen last winter, hypothermia kills the elderly; however small the numbers involved, they are all unnecessary deaths. It is the state that is, at present imposed upon to provide a solution to the awful problem of old people freezing to death. So it should be. We pride ourselves upon being a compassionate society and there can be few more uncompassionate acts than allowing the relatively helpless to perish in this fashion."

Now, the pedantic might want to take issue with the Telegraph over just how "small the numbers of hypothermia victims were last winter; official figures put it at around 600 people aged 65 or over. Age Concern reckon the true figure for last year was 44,000 pensioners dying from illness related to the cold.

But the point is that the Telegraph cares and it believes that the state is "imposed upon" to "provide a solution" to this "awful problem"

The semi-official mouthpiece of Home Counties Toryism even goes so far as to administer a gentle rap to the knuckles of the Thatcher administration:

"If the government thinks it has discharged its responsibilities in this area adequately by offering a £5 supplement per week to the elderly when the duration of cold weather conforms with absurdly bureaucratic guidelines, it is deceiving itself."

What does Mr Norman Tebbit (who it is said recently dismissed calls for a more "caring" government image with the words "No one with a conscience votes Conservative anyway") have to say about this?

Will the Telegraph's column inches be measured for clear anti-government bias? Is Max Hastings to be denounced as a closet pinko? This seems unlikely. The Telegraph's other leading article is an enthusiastic plug for privatisation. It has evidently not occured to the Telegraph that the fundamental reason for old people freezing to death in the winter in that fuel is simply too expensive. Gas and electricity charges are determined by the government's wish to raise revenue, not by the ability of people to pay. And privatisation has made the situation very much worse.

An even more extraordinary result of the cold snap manifested itself in Tuesday's Daily Mail - an editorial in praise of British Rail and British Rail staff: *BR is underfunded (compared to the subsidies pumped into other railways abroad); understaffed in the South (where vacancies remain unfilled because of housing costs); and unloved.

"Just this once, maybe, we should leave our grumbles in the deep freeze and thaw out some gratitude for the effort most railwaymen are making in these most appalling conditions...

This is remarkable stuff from the publication that generally most loyally reflects Mrs Thatcher's well-known dislike of the railways and is a favourite weapon (when rolled up) in the hands of enraged commuters pursuing BR staff down platforms.

What has brought all this on? Could it be because the South East has been hardest hit by the cruel Siberian winds? Is it just a little chilly, even in the editorial offices of the Telegraph and Mail? And why do they not ask where the money is to come from to pay for more generous heating allowances for the elderly or to provide BR with more adequate subsidies?

It is indeed remarkable what sub-zero temperatures can do to the political outlook of the Tory press. Suddenly profit isn't everything. There's a role for the state and even for subsidies to BR.

Meanwhile Age Concern has issued some advice to pensioners which could prove particularly useful in the event of the week's temperature not averaging 1.5°C, and the f5 'Exceptionally Cold Weather Payment' not being made - stay in bed and wrap yourself up in old newspapers.

Now there's a really good use for copies of the Telegraph and the Mail. consistently as to the trajectory of the majority on the National Executive.

Your correspondent is well aware (or should be) of all this and yet he asserts the contrary.

He then goes further and compounds his lie by stating that I "lay the blame for any shoddy future deal at the door of the English teachers" Again Ross must be well aware (or he should be of the many efforts by myself and other CFFU supporters to strengthen solidarity between Scottish, English and Welsh teachers through exchanges of literature and viously he is operating on the principle of shooting on sight at anything truthful.

It would be idle to speculate as to why Ross, a long-time SW supporter, should resort to such a tawdry parade of lies. It may be seen as an attempt in some way to reverse the marginal and declining influence of SW among Scottish teachers. Obviously it will be rejected with the contempt it deserves and assuredly produce a result the opposite of that intended.

Yours fraternally, IAN McCALMAN

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 298

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →