Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The scandal of NOLS

Socialist Organiser no. 298, 15 January 1987 · scan p. 7 · about 1,763 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

"'the union leaders tried quickly as possible" gned an agreement with manageient and called for a return to work y their members.

The CGT, CFDT and FGAAC ndependent General Federation of rivers) refused to sign the agreelent.

The rank and file strikers — who ere often not in any union at all -et up their own co-ordinating committees: an inter-regional cordinating committee based at the aris North station, and a national -ordinating committee consisting i delegates from local strike comattees.

Leadership

The CGT leadership responded by uestioning "the motivation of eating a co-ordinating body which going to short-circuit the representive trade union bodies...Public pinion is being tricked, and an at-mpt is being made to take over the ilway workers' strike for a political eration which bears not a trace of ontaneity." The CGT singled out + attack CFDT official Daniel try, as the man behind the moves to side-step official union structures.

The CFDT responded by joining in the attack on their own official. A CFDT statement condemned "the action currently being led by Daniel Vitry" and announced that Vitry was to be the object of an internal union inquiry on the grounds that he was not acting in line with his union mandate.

But the union leaderships were also forced to sound more militant: Henri Krasucki of the CGT declared: "The CGT will do everything to ensure that the movement of struggle grows" and "Let the tide rise! Unlike other union officials we are not afraid of the workers.

The French magazine Le Point summed up the dilemma of the union leaders: "Forced to act with extreme carefulness in order to be neither disavowed nor outflanked (by their members)...To face the unpopularity be public opiniom their base a such being cut oft from their base is the uncomfortable alternative with which all unions (i.e. union leaders) are therefore confronted, henceforth ›laced "under surveillance" by their members." tion in the National Organisation of Labour Students (NOLS) maintained its stranglehold over the organisation last weekend by bureaucratically and unjustly depriving delegates opposed to the ruling faction of their votes.

The opposition had a majority, but the incumbent young bureaucrats had the power, and they used it like Stalinists (and many of them are, in fact, soft Labour Party Stalinists) — without scruple and in defiance of the elementary rules of democracy.

The occasion was the NOLS "Studelegates to run for election to the dent Council" which selected National Union of Students (NUS) Executive at the Easter NUS conference.

Using blatantly undemocratic manoeuvres, they managed to secure a narrow majority for the "soft left", the ridiculously (Orwellianly) misnamed "Democratic Left" faction. To keep control, the registration desk totted up the figures, assessed the weight of the different factions and then found excuses to rule enough delegates out of order to ensure their own fake majority.

Then, when the "Democratic Left" 'majority' had been established, incumbent NUS president Vicky Phillips debated Simon Pottinger so that the meeting could decide who should be NOLS candidate for President at next NUS conference. Phillips beat Pottinger by 14 votes: but 17 opposition votes had been unjustly disqualified.

This is the latest episode in a long and sorry tale of such stitch-ups. Although the "Democratic Left" claim to stand for "pluralism' and 'democratic socialism' , and claim to be opposed to *sectarian manipulation' "Leninism' and other sins they say are associated with organised socialist groups, in fact they function as a hard, disciplined political faction, sacrificing principles of democracy for the objective of 'keepling control'.

NOLS national conferences notorious for the bureaucratic procedures that "have kept the "Democratic Left" in control. Oppositionists have been 'carved out' year after year.

The way these people run NOLS is a scandal to the labour movement. The examples of their chicanery are legion.

Last year, one of the NOLS auditors was Dave Brennan, a supporter of Socialist Students in NOLS (SSiN). He was not allowed to see anything more than a statement of income and expenditure. Denied the right to see correspondence from Clubs, receipts or membership cards, against which income could be measured, Dave refused to sign the accounts.

The "Democratic Left" 'majority' voted to refuse to allow David to speak about why he could not say the accounts were a true and accurate record.

Ruled out

In 1983 a whole range of Labour Clubs and delegates who supported opposition points of view were ruled out'. At Manchester University, all delegates who opposed the "Democratic Left" were disqualified and DL supporters, who had been elected as observers, were promoted into delegates.

Oppositionists were ruled out because - so it was claimed - they had not filled in their cards properly. When this claim was challenged, the cards were said to have been lost!

Conference overturned the Student Organiser's recommendation and it was the last occasion on which the conference was allowed to challenge the credentials report.

The same year, a DL member on the National Committee, Dave Mason, was proven to have forged a signature to get the SSiN supporter on the Birmingham University delegation disqualified.

Every year there are new examples of barefaced and shameless fiddling like this.

More than fiddling and opportunist cheating is involved though. Kinnock The basic structures of NOLS are not fully democratic, nor is NOLS open to all students. Part-time Further Education students — who are heavily working class, far more so than University and Polytechnic students — are not entitled to join NOLS!

The Student Council itself - scene last weekend's display of but democratic. In fact it has only 'consultative status' - the National Committee can overrule it. And it is enormously weighted in favour of Student Union Otticers. Anyone on a student union executive who has a NOLS card can vote there - swamping elected delegates from Labour Clubs. bent bureaucrats face defeat, even playing such a rigged game. What do they do when the opposition looks like winning? They change the rules!

In 1984, a non-sabbatical member of Manchester Area NUS executive, Rachel Kennedy, was given voting credentials. Other non-sabbatical Area Exeuctive members have voted since. This year because PEne " Democratic Left's narrow majority depended on it, all such NOLS members were ruled ineligible to More even than that. This year's Student Council was rigged in advance.

All Labour Clubs have to give four days' written notice to their members. before discussing business Yet notification of the Student Council was not sent out until December 5: college terms would either have finished before a meeting could be held, or before notification had been received. And the Council meeting took place before the new term began at many colleges.

Against previous custom and practice, delegates appointed by Labour Club Executives - in the absence of a properly convened club meeting were not allowed to vote.

Also against custom and practice, NOLS National Committee members - all but two of whom, of course, supported the DL - were given a The rules are whatever the "Democratic Left" faction say they are - from year to year and from hour to hour. Their guiding principle is plainly the notorious Stalinist rule of conduct. "We do what necessary, comrade!"

Opposition clubs' delegate entitlements to national conference have been gerrymandered as well. When North Staffs Poly asked for some more NOLS cards, the NOLS office cancelled the ones they had already received. Other clubs have received far too few cards and were not sent the extra ones they have requested until very close to the deadline for returning them to NOLS. Yet without properly completed cards, returned to the NOLS office by the proper date, they will not be entitled to the full number of delegates at the conference.

Why do the "Democratic Left" resort to these undemocratic practices? Although they function as a hard faction under the political control of the Clause 4 organisation, there is very little that unites the DL politically. What does unite them is their support for Neil Kinnock (even if many of them are quietly critical), and their loathing for "Trotskyists'. Some of them, like NOLS chairperson, Ben Lucas, are open witchhunters.

As the DL have moved further and further to the right, NOLS has all but collapsed as a distinct political group. The DL majority on NUS Executive has blundered from one fiasco to the next.

Within NUS and within NOLS, SSiN has emerged as a coherent, fighting, socialist opposition, able to unite wide layers of students around a strategy based on mass action and linking up with the working class.

Whole parts of NUS policy - on cuts, and on general strategy — have come from SSiN, forcing the DL on NUS Executive to stall, and junk their own conference mandates.

The "Democratic Left" have no idea how to fight for student interests. As they decay, they are taking NOLS and NUS down with them. So more and more students are looking to SSIN as an alternative. And bureaucratic stitch-ups are the only way they can hold onto their control.

The bureaucratic inertia that afflicts NOLS, and thus NUS, will actually prove self-defeating even to the electoral objectives the DL have set. To win the youth vote for Labour, an ongoing campaigning approach is needed - oriented in particular to working class youth in Further Education colleges.

Yet the national demonstration that NUS has finally called will be on a Saturday - when many FE students have to work (and when coordinated action by college trade unions will not be possible).

Fix Faced with a disgusting, undemocratic fix, SSiN supporters walked out of the Student Council, after the rigged meeting - that is, in real terms a minority of the meeting - voted to support DL candidate Vicky Phillips for NUS President, the post she currently holds.

The DL cannot continue in this style indefinitely. No amount of manipulation can cover up their political failures.

Joining NOLS is very difficult. Not only are working class youth from the Further Education colleges ineligible for membership, but NOLS groups which the "Democratic Left" does not control are refused recognition.

Yet NOLS is the student wing of the mass working class party: it is worthwhile for socialist students to fight their way in to settle accounts with the bureaucrats who are stifling NOLS. SSiN's message to student activists is: Join NOLS! Join the fight to transform NOLS into a democratic campaigning socialist student movement!

Socialist Students in NOLS can be contacted at 54a Peckham Rye, London SE15.

----- pull-quotes -----

and Jane Ashworth But, even so, sometimes the incum-

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 298

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →