Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The NHS: lethal in their hands

Socialist Organiser no. 298, 15 January 1987 · scan pp. 5–7 · Jean Lane · about 2,903 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

union not a Socialist Organiser no.298. January 1987. Page 5 115th The Health Service is safe with the Tories, we were told at the last election. Since then Fowler has assured us of how many millions he is ploughing in. Well, I don't know where those millions are going, but one thing's for sure, it's not going into hospital beds, wards or general health facilities. So perhaps Fowler's paying it to himself?

Last November a man I know. collapsed while he was visiting a friend. He was writhing in pain and vomiting. His friend phoned his doctor who told her to bring him to the surgery when it opened at 4 pm. This was at 11 am. So she phoned her own doctor who told her that he couldn't come out because the man wasn't his patient - medical ethics and all that. In desperation she phoned the hospital who told her not to bring him in because they hadn't got a free bed. She took him anyway and for seven hours he lay on a trolley in a corridor till they could find a patient union?

*We are of the opinion that without strong and free trade unions, there cannot be strong socialism. (Rapturous applause)...Nothing happens here in the absence of consultation with, and co-determination by, the trade unions. The members of the party and state leadership of the German Democratic Republic are themselves members of trade unions, in some cases already for decades."

With these words Erick Honnecker East German head of state, opened the 11th Congress of the World Federation of Trade Unions (WFTU), held in East Berlin in September of 1986. It was attended by 1,014 delegates claiming to represent 296 million workers, organised in 432 "trade unions" in 154 different countries.

But far from all the organisations represented at the congress were genuire trade unions.

Set up in 1945 in Paris and now based in Prague, the WFTU. is an umbrella organisation comprising the fake state-run "unions" of the Stalinist states, Communist Partycontrolled trade unions in the West Edmund Baluka, Polish socialist appositionist, jailed for his "crimes" to send home so he could have a bed.

It turned out that the man had a stone in his kidney that was so big they had to operate, cut into his kidney, to get it out. Four days after the operation he was sent home, no doubt because some other poor sod was lying in the corridor waiting for a bed.

Within a week my friend had collapsed again and was rushed back in with a blood clot on his lung — apparently a common occurence in old people atter surgery. This must have been known along with the fact that my friend has a history of heart trouThe Health Service that Fowler is running is not the one that I envisage. It is a conveyor-belt, speed-up system similar to the Fords production line, where defective parts inevitably come off the end of the track and where cure is better than prevention.

That reminds me of an experience of my own. When the effects of 20 years of women taking the pill eventually became known a couple of years ago, and there were reports of side-effects such as cancer, heart en Is a and elsewhere, and trade unions or organisations purporting to be trade unions in Third World countries linked politically or economically with the USSR.

Honecker's opening comments were therefore accurate, albeit in the opposite of the intended sense. The absence of independent trade unions in the Stalinist states exposes the hollowness of their claims to be advancing the cause of socialism. And the overlap in membership between the ruling state bureaucracy and the "trade unions" is evidence of control by the former over the latter, rather than an expression of workers' control over "their" state.

Thus what WFTU President Sandor Gaspar (also President of the National Council of Hungarian "Trade Unions") described in an eve-ofconference press conference as "the highest forum of the world trade union movement" included representation from such unlikely "trade union" organisations as:

•The Central Council of Afghan Trade Unions and the Ethopian Trade Union Federation (state-run labour-front organisations being constructed on the Soviet model);

•The Polish state trade union OPZZ, (an attempt to construct a new state-run "trade union" after the suppression of Solidarnosc);

•The Liaison Commission of Iranian Trade Unions (a rump organisation representing nothing at all, set up by the Moscow-loyal Iranian Tudeh Party);

•The South African Congress of Trade Unions (an organisation of extremely modest proportions, heavily overshadowed by COSAT -though this did not prevent WTU general secretary • Ibrahim Zakaria describing it as "the true representative of the South African trade union movement"');

•The fake state-run "unions" of the Eastern bloc states (the role of which was summed up by Shalayev, chairperson of the Central Council of the Soviet "unions" as being "the greatest possible intensification trouble, sterility, nausea, etc., decided that it was time to come off it. I was in a high-risk group - taking the pill for over ten years, from before I was twenty-five, a highBy Jean Lane oestrogen pill and a heavy smoker to boot.

So I went to the clinic, having done some research of my own, to tell them I want to go onto the cap instead; this being a method of contraception which seemed almost as reliable, more convenient and with the least danger from side-effects.

Feeling quite pleased with myself for taking my well-being into my own hands, I strolled in and made my anGorbachev explains the importan productivity in order to achieve an increase in the tempo of economic growth").

However, not all organisations represented at the congress were fake unions. Luminaries of the Western trade union movement attending the Congress included Campbell Christie (Scottish TUC General Secretary), Ken Gill and a cil), Stan Fitzsimmons (President of the Fire Brigades Union) and William Wallace (Irish TUC vice-president). British and Irish trade unionists will doubtless take heart from the company their leaders keep In his opening speech to the congress, Gaspar stressed the alleged openness of the event. It was open to all trade all trade iliated to the WETU And freedom of debate would be the order of the day "everyone has the possibility of stating their opinions, openly and with equal rights.

On the first point Gaspar was correct. 452 delegates were members of WFTU-affiliates, as against 562 delegates who were members of unions affiliated to other international federations or of non-aligned unions. But genuine debate was notable for its apsence from the Congress. Speeches were merely pieces.

such as the "Appeat to Trade Unions in All Countries"' were adopted without the moving of And the WFTU Presinouncement. L was met with a stoney, poker face, the owner of which demanded to know why I was putting them to all this trouble. The pill is easy, you see. You go in, get a quick weight and blood pressure test -once a year a cancer smear - and come out the other end with 6 months of birth control. The clinic is so busy that so long as everybody wants the same thing it can run relatively smoothly with a conveyor belt of scales, pressure pumps and dispensary. I, with my proud announcement, was a spanner in the works.

I explained that I no longer wished to take the risks that went with using the pill. The reply I got went something like this: "These Americans have got so much money they don't know what to do with it. So they bang out another research project and report. One year it's sugar, the next it's salt or butter, and this year it's the pill. It doesn't mean anything.

I dug my heels in and said I wanted the cap, not cancer. (So why are you a heavy smoker?) The woman picked up my ten cancer smear test reports çe of hard work Presidents and seven secretaries were elected/re-elected unopposed.

Three main themes were taken up by the Congress, with separate commissions set up to deal with each of them and submit a report for approval by the congress: peace and disarmament; economic and social questions; and, rather hypocritically, trade union rights.

The commission's sessions were characterised by a combination of accurate condemnation of prevailing conditions in the capitalist West, coupled with fanciful claims about the workers' wonderlands of the Stalinist states.

Thus, the commission on peace and disarmament, like the congress as a whole, was predictably to witness an unending series of speeches praising Soviet "peace initiatives" • such as the moratorium on testing nuclear weapons, and condemning America for its 'Star Wars' programme and its responsibility for heightening international tensions.

The way to preserve peace was to strengthen the economies of the "socialist" states. As Honecker put it: "An expression of their (East German workers') desire for peace is that on the occasion of World Peace Day (1 September) 3,725,000 workers achieved maximum shift performances...Their most striking expression is the slogan: 'My place of work - my place of struggle for peace' "

The latest congress of this sham trade union' federation fulfilled from my file, shook them at me ar said, "There's your insurance again that!" Not impressed with my desi to prevent getting cancer, she ju wanted to be able to inform me whe Ed got it!

Like the nurses in my friend hospital, this woman was massive over-worked in a cold and inadequa building and underpaid - workir against all odds just to keep an inad quate system tiding over rather tha to provide a necessary and urgent se vice.

In this next election, Fowler is gi ing to sell us more rubbish abor what he is providing. In fact he wi be selling our health service - dow the river. I think we should teach hir and the rest of the Tories exact] what is meant by "prevention rathe than cure". Let's cut this cancer ou and prevent it from returning t make us sick. That means performin an emergency operation on th Labour Party, so that it is no longer sticking plaster over the scars capitalism, but a real working clas alternative which will provide the ser vices we need. a dual purpose.

On the one hand, it was a stagt managed performance designed t boost the fake-socialist credentials c the Soviet bureaucracy and it equivalent in other countries, b falsely portraying the Stalinist state as peace-loving (despite thei readiness to use violence to crus workers' uprisings), havens 9 economic and social progress (despit the backward and crisis-ridde nature of their economies), an custodians of trade union right (despite the absence of genuin unions and their crushing of attempt to establish independent trad On the other hand, it also marke a further step towards attempting tr create a single united internationa federation involving all trade union and organisations purporting to b trade unions — which, in practice would function as a medium throug! which Stalinism would strengthen it influence in the labour movements o capitalist countries.

However bureaucratically run an limited in their internal democracy the latter remain, nonetheless, in dependent workers' organisations, a distinct trom the state-run organisa tions of the Stalinist states which pas themselves off as trade unions.

Socialists should certainly suppor the creation of a single federation o trade unions, but not what is on offe from the WFTU: a stitch-up betweet union bureaucrats in the West and Stalinist functioraries in the East.

Scan page 6

Last week Stan Crooke reported on the current student/worker revolt in France up to 8 December 1986, when the government backed down on its education cuts. This week's article CFDT urtered support under strict not want violence." The PS refused conditions (such as preservation of to support the demonstration of 10 the non-party-political nature of the December and refused to be even ofstudent movement, and limitation of fıcially represented at it. So much for CFDT condemned the demonstration response to students' appeals for supThe FEN did much the same. Only as the start of a big offensive. the CGT called for strikes on 10 A recent opinion poll showed that Monde" put it: "clearly, the unions PCF attempted to explain such a loss do not want to replay May 1968 in of support as being the result of a ecem er 1986,* referring to the "shift to the right by society". And it general strike of May 13 1968 called maintained that line even after the by the CGT, CFDT, FO, CGC and students' victory. strikes and factory occupations in- PS and the PCF were mortified (or, dependent of the control of the union in the case of the PCF, bemused For the Socialist Party general the students. But rank and file THE RIGHT WING government's retreat was an opportunity for the unions, the Socialist Party (PS) and the Communist Party (PC) to rally to the cause of the students and make their victorious struggle the start of a class-wide counter-offensive against the RPR-UDF government. But they didn't.

Before 10 December the students asked the unions to call strikes on that day in solidarity with the students' mass demonstration.

The right wing unions - CGC, CFTC, FO - flatly refused. The Chirac brings the story up to date.

demands to purely student ones).

When Chirac backed down, the of 10 December as "inopportune and sent only a token delegation.

December.

As the French daily "Le tified politically with the CP.

"AN which unleashed a wave of leaderships.

December: The PCF had played *We are not embarrassed to say that we are in complete solidarity (with the student movement)." took it seriously.

But nine days later Jospin declared: We socialists, we want the return of calm... We do not want a the year strikes erupted. political crisis in this country. We do Strikers tell scab what to do supply industry) took part in a token four-hour strike in the morning of 11 December after the breakdown of talks between union and management over pay. 25,000 demonstrated in Paris, though only 31% of the Workforce supported the strike, apparently due to its token nature.

There was more widespread support for a strike on 17 December, forcing a reduction of 21,800 megawatts in electricity generation.

Merchant seamen and staff of the Air Inter airline joined the growing strike movement. Shipping at most complete solidarity" Atlantic and Mediterranean ports The PCF had been more positive in was brought to a standstill within days of 10 December, and the Air Inport than the PS, but it was equally ter strike cut flights by 15% and the unwilling to take the students' victory number of passengers carried by 35%, before it ended on December only 3% of French students idenParis In| the RATP (Paris public transport) a strike began on 22 December, called by the independent union of drivers, which covers some So the leaders of the unions, the 50% of the RATP train drivers (bus services were not affected). Supported by 59% of the drivers, the rather than inspired by the struggle of strike cut Paris underground rail services by an average of 60%.

A strike on the SNCF (French railways) began on 18 December and slogan "Struggle pays off" in the was effectively to paralyse the rail aftermath of the student revolt, but network within a week.lt spread did not put it into practice. Workers from involving only drivers at the outset to drawing in support from ofIn the fortnight between the vic- fice staff and other sections of the tory of the students and the end of workforce. Stations were occupied and lines blocked to prevent scab Workers in the EDF (electricity trains running in some parts of the country.

The question of pay rises was at the centre of many of the strikes (although especially in the SNCF dispute a number of other issues were involved as well). Workers in the EDF and SNCF had not had a pay rise since 1985. If the RPR-UDF government is successful in its plans. to keep down pay rises, they can look forward to no more than a 3% pay rise, like the rest of the public sector.

But the union leaders tried to end the strikes as quickly as possible.

The CGT publicly stated at the start that it would not support the RATP strike though it subsequently mellowed its tone.

The CFDT likewise condemned the strike as veing too sectional and concerned only with the demands of the drivers, and expressed its tears of "the risks engendered by this unpopular strike"

The CFDT also went on to condemn the SNCF strike, attacking, for the sake of "balance" the "blind technocrats" who kept down wages and also denouncing "with equal vigour the stubborn and irresponsible movements in the process of paralysing the country."

Such a strike, it claimed, could only devalue "true trade unionism"!

But as the SNCF strike intensified, the union leaderships were forced to change their tactics. Denunciation had failed to end the strike, so the Leaderships declared their support for it, in order to be able to sell it out and -call it off. On 23 December, the CFTC, the CGC and the FMC (an autonomous union grouping the higher grades of SNCF employees)

Scan page 7

The controlling pro-Kinnock fac-

----- pull-quotes -----

retreats, workers advance

secretary Lionel Jospin said on 14 worker delayed with the the

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 298

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →