Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Unfair to Militant?

Socialist Organiser no. 298, 15 January 1987 · scan p. 4 · Simon Lawlor · about 706 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Reader report 5 Nov 2026 (garbled): the machine reading had interleaved this letter's columns with the Graffiti items beside it (Tunas, AIDS). Transcribed from the scan of page 4. A letter, signed Simon Lawlor, North Nottingham LPYS, answering Bas Hardy's article in SO 296.

Proofed text: read against the scan word by word; spelling, punctuation and wording are as printed.

Scan page 4

Anyone looking for a coherent analysis of the dispute between Liverpool City Council and the Black Caucus would have been disappointed by the article in SO 296 by Bas Hardy.

Although the page it was featured on was called “Analysis”, there was little of this. Instead Bas Hardy repeated without any care for the facts about the record of Liverpool City Council on racism.

For example, Hardy quotes a Social Services Department report on the number of elderly blacks receiving “meals on wheels”, day care facilities and in residential homes. What Hardy doesn’t reveal is that these figures relate to the time the Liberals controlled the council. Under Labour, since 1983, in Liverpool 8, the number of black people who had meals on wheels, etc., has increased from the 0.3% quoted by Hardy to 13% by the end of 1985!

On housing, in Liverpool 8, the Council has spent more on its housing budget than any other Local Authority’s total housing budget. The Council have built 978 dwellings in Liverpool 8, and they have carried out large scale improvements to 1782 dwellings.

On the question of jobs, over 20% of all new intakes have been black. In fact the worst area for recruitment both before and since the Bond Affair occurred is the clerical section where appointments are made in conjunction with NALGO.

On the Bond Affair, even the Black Caucus book admits that the majority of councillors on the selection panel were not Militant supporters. Hardly a Militant coup! One thing that comes through the whole book is the complete lack of any strategy on the part of the Black Caucus to tackle racism. Their whole ideology is based on the old “consensus” between the Race Relations “industry” and the establishment.

The Black Caucus’s claim to be truly representative of the black community was shown to be false in the May 1986 council elections. They stood a candidate against Labour in Granby ward. They got a miserable 477 votes, completely smashed by Labour’s 2287 votes. The majority of local black community organisations call for the lifting of the boycott on Sam Bond.

The Black Caucus has the support of the Liberals, the five rebel councillors who wouldn’t vote for an illegal budget, Neil Kinnock, sections of the Churches, Tories and some businessmen.

In 1986 the Black Caucus gave evidence to the House of Commons Select Committee on Employment. They stated that Littlewoods was a good example of what can be done to fight discrimination against blacks. Coincidentally Littlewoods employs a Black Caucus supporter as “race advisor”. In actual fact, Littlewoods only employ 22 blacks out of 7,000 workers in the Liverpool area (or 0.8%). The whole dispute on Sam Bond relates to the Black Caucus being cheesed off that they haven’t landed a well-paid, plush job.

Some other points about Bas Hardy’s article. He states that Tony Byrne was installed as Leader of the Council after “last month’s putsch ousted John Hamilton”. In fact, as anybody should know, Hamilton had joined forces with the Labour Party bureaucracy in trying to keep the expelled councillors out of Labour Group meetings. The majority of councillors considered the expulsions wrong and wanted to let the expelled councillors stay in the group. It’s normally the right wing who talk about “putsches” and people being “ousted”!

Bas Hardy also quotes Trotsky and James P. Cannon as a stick to beat Militant with. Would Socialist Organiser call for a separate black state in Britain as Hardy implied or are these rantings of “Bas” just his personal opinion.

An analysis of the Liverpool experience is needed but Bas Hardy can’t provide one. In all his articles over the last year or so there is a real thread of spite, slander and nitpicking. Most of Hardy’s fury seems to come from the fact that Militant do have a lot of support on Merseyside whilst Bas Hardy is becoming more and more isolated because he has been incapable of building a tendency all the many years he has been involved in revolutionary politics. Socialist Organiser should take the trouble to get someone who deals with facts before commissioning reviews such as the one in SO 296.

Yours comradely, SIMON LAWLOR, North Nottingham LPYS

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 298

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →