Ideal stories
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-01-08Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
Stan Crooke examines the French labour movement and its record. The concluding part will be published next week.
At the close of 1986 the working class movement in Frahce found itself in a situation comparable to that faced by the British labour movement at the close of 1979Just as the British working class had had its strength partially sapped by the pro-capitalist Labour government of 1974-79 and, by the end of 1979, found itself confronted by a viciously right-wing Tory: government, so too the record of the French "socialist" government of 1981-86 demoralised French workers and paved the way for the return of an overtly right-wing government led by Jacques Chirac in March of 1986.
The record of the Socialist Party (PS) in power in 1981-6 — in coalition with the French Communist Party (PCF) for the first three years -was as sorry as that of the Labour government of Wilson and Callaghan. Initial reforms such as a cut in the working week, an extra week of annual holidays, some nationalisations at price of extravagant compensation, and a tax on wealth which left the latter largely untouched, all turned out to be mere gestures rather than real inroads into the power of capital.
And token gestures in favour of workers soon gave way to real attacks on workers. Wages were held down, cutbacks were made in the social security system, unemployment was allowed to increase, living standards fell for many, and racism flourished as immigrant workers were scapegoated for the crisis of capitalism.
Faithful to its capitalist masters, the PS-PCF government subdued the militancy of the workers' movement: the growth of unemployment to some three millions cost unions members and made workers more hesitant about taking action - by mid-1986 the rate of strikes in the private sector of the economy was at its lowest for Growing unemployment also meant a falling union membership. Between 1968 and 1985, for example, the membership of the PCFcontrolled trade union federation (including retired workers maintaining their membership) fell from over 2,100,000 to 1,622,095. This weakened the mobilising capacities of the The stage had thus been well prepared for the entry of the RPRUDF government - five years of back-tracking by a government "of the left" and a weakening of the self-confidence of the working class which the new government was prepared to exploit to the full, by continuing and intensifying the anti-working class and socially reactionary policies of its predecessor.
RPR-UDF legislation already carried out or in preparation includes: wide-ranging privatisations, an increase in the legal maximum working week, a new racist nationality code, abolition of trial by jury for "terrorist" offences, attacks on tenants' rights, cutbacks in social security, an amnesty for currency speculators, increased powers for the police, etc., etc.
However, despite a basic similarity between the situation of the British labour movement at the close of 1979 and that of French workers at the close of 1986, there are also important and potentially far-reaching differences.
These are partly the result of difterences between the British and French labour movements and political systems, and partly the result of the events of December of last Riot cops attack striking rail workers The PS can only roughly be compared with the Labour Party. It is neither a trade on creation, nor a trade union based organisation at present. Nor, unlike the Labour Party, has it been the party for which workers have traditionally cast their vote: not until the mid-1970s did the PS overtake the PCF in terms of overall electoral popularity (but even then, not necessarily working class electoral popularity). And the ongoing, if declining, significance of the PCF represents a further difference between the political organisation of British and French workers.
Thus, the rank and file campaign for democracy and accountability which mushroomed in the Labour Party after the 1979 election defeat is unlikely to be — and, indeed, has not been - repeated in the PS or, even less so, the PCF.
Even more significant is the difference between British and French trade union organisation. Whereas in Britain there is just one trade union federation , there are a variety of national, regional and industrial trade union organisations in France.
Metamorphosis
The largest unions are the PCFcontrolled CGT and the CFDT (originally a Catholic breakaway from the CGT in 1919, which changed its name from "French Confederation of Christian Workers" to *Democratic French Confederation of Labour" in 1964). The second rank unions are FO (a 1947 breakaway from the CGT, in protest at a wave of PCF and CGT-inspired strikes) and CFTC (the continuation of those sections of the "French Confederation of Christian Workers" opposed to the metamorphosis into the CFDT).
In addition there are a number of smaller trade union organisations, such as the pro-Gaullist CGC which recruits from the higher grades of employees and management, the national teachers' union (FEN) which covers some 90% of teachers, the CFT (French Confederation of Labour), the CAT (Autonomous Confederation of Labour), plus various other much smaller union organisations covering just workers in one specific industry in one particular area.
The result of this proliferation of trade union organisations is not a higher level of organisation than in Britain, but a lower level of unionisation, due to the divisions into different unions which weakens the overall position of the trade union movement in France: in general only 20-25% of the total French labour force is unionised.
This overall weakness of French trade unionism, exacerbated by the growth of unemployment under the PS-PCF government, meant that the French union movement was in a relatively weaker position at the time of the RPR-UDF electoral victory than that of the British unions at the time of Thatcher's 1979 victory. On the other hand, although weakened by the "socialist" government's policies, the French unions had not been decisively defeated.
A further difference between 1979 Britain and 1986 France lies in the nature of the French system of government, in which major powers are concentrated in the hands of the President (elected once every seven years on the basis of universal suffrage, in separate elections from Parliamentary elections).
Although the RPR-UDF won control of the National Assembly, the President remained Francois Mitterrand, victorious candidate of the PS in the 1981 Presidential elections. Conflict might therefore have been expected between a right-wing controlled parliament and a PS President with vast constitutional powers.
But it would certainly be wrong to regard President Mitterrand as a focus for working class opposition to the new government. The powers of the French President make the French political system even less democratic than the British one. And the last thing to which Mitterrand was, and is, accountable to is the rank and file of the French labour movement.
In tact, a cause of much greater concern to the new RPR-UDF government than the existence of a "Left" President was the growth in support for the fascist FN (National Front) of Le Pen. The growth of the FN posed a direct threat to the French labour movement. It also militated against the possibility of the RPR-UDF government making concessions, for fear of losing support to the FN, an additional factor in the situation in France not present in Britain. in 1979, when the fascists sustained heavy losses at the polls.
However, by far the major difference between the situation of the French working class in the aftermath of the RPR-UDF election victory and that of the British one in the opening period of Thatcher's government lies in the events of December of last year.
Inevitable
The first major test of strength faced by Thatcher was the steelworkers' strike of early 1980. Although the Tories' victory in that conflict did not make inevitable their victory in disputes in subsequent years, it certainly strengthened their standing and their hopes of achieving further such successes. But in France the new RPR-UDF government was defeated in the first decisive test of strength: the attempted attack on higher education.
Student opposition to the attacks mushroomed and won in a matter of weeks. On 22 November a general assembly of 1,500 student delegates met to plan the campaign. On 23 November 200,000 marched on a demonstration called by FEN (the one exception to the hitherto low level of trade union mobilisations), and 200,000 marched again on 27 November on a student demonstration, as student strikes spread throughout French universities. On Thursday 4 December, 800,000 marched through Paris. Demonstrations and street clashes continued over the weekend, costing one student his life. On Monday the government backed down completely. And on the Wednesday (10 December) hundreds of thousands again marched through Paris in mourning for the dead student and in celebration of the victory.
recently stomped out of the Ne According to John Pilger, rho on Sunday project, one of the proposed headlines for a dum my issue was Dirty Den has AIDS It was, said the editor, an id eal story, "combining popular app seal and social awareness" It was t this trend that led Pilger to resign as editor-in-chief shortly beft bre Christmas.
It is probably only a matter of ti before one of the tabloids does ca that headline indeed, they already come close when the S Star, News of the World et etc., discovered that actor Leslie Gri tham's brother may have died of 1 disease.
I thought of that headline as I re a piece in the Guardian about 1 the mysterious Rocky Ryan. If and wh the story does appear it will be e en money that it is a Ryanette.
Rocky (if it was indeed he) expla ed the initial motivation behind | unusual hobby/crusade: back in 19 he was stitched up by a Sun repor during the Black Panther hunt. A:
result Rocky was arrested by arm police at 2 a.m. while the Sun's m looked scribbling down his scoop.
Since then Rocky has exacted I revenge by conning most of the n tional press with asemes of ho stories fed with a panache and cun ing that borders on genius.
Rocky outlined his philosophy the Guardian: "they make them 1 anyway, don't they? People in t Pires are the lowest form of hum:
They crucify people that car defend themselves sO they're fa game too, the bastards. There's r way I'd pull the strokes some of yc lot pull. I'd never do anything to re: ly hurt."
Rocky's artistry lies in identifyir just the right story to set the hack pulses racing (royalty, the Moo Murderers, Dirty Den, etc., etc thinking up a spicy and. just abo believable 'angle', researching his subject extensively enough to give veneer of authenticity, and "feeding' it with a Thespian skill tha would do Sir Lawrence proud.
We can chalk up such fiction: tabloid 'coups' as the story that Lor Lucan had been spotted in Sout Africa, the report that Peter Sutcliff had been made a trusty by priso authorities, the summoning by th Queen of Princess Michael to meeting to discuss the latter's mar riage crisis, and the Star exclusiv that Dirty Den was about to leav East Enders.
He is also responsible for a con siderable proportion of the coverag given to Prince Charles, Colone Quadaffi and Moira Hindley although James Anderton can pro bably claim more credit for thi Hindley stories.
A recent bold departure was tr feed a true story to the Sunday Spor (nice one!) and then, the following week, denounce it as a hoax to the Sunday People who fell for it hook line and sinker. He then gilded the li ly by sending Robert Maxwell a de mand for £500 for filling a page.
But Rocky has a problem: no-one can tell which stories are Ryanettes and which are naturally occurring products of the hacks' fertile im agination. For instance, the News of the World continues to stand by its story about Princess Michael and the Queen, denying any Ryan involve ment. How are we to tell?
Rocky now plans to issue advance notice of his strokes so that there will be no confusion. How he will do this I do not know. An alternative scam might be to go legit and sign up with the News on Sunday.
January 1987. Page 9
Scan page 10
iŞan REVIEWS C