Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

[FACED with rising anti-semitism in late 19th century…]

Socialist Organiser no. 297, 8 January 1987 · scan p. 4 · about 652 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

FACED with rising anti-semitism in late 19th century Britain, Eleanor Marx used to declare at public meetings, 'I am a Jewess'.

Strictly speaking she wasn't, but she wanted to confront the anti-semites head on.

The position of Mick Ackersley and Jack Cleary is in some ways similar. Faced with anti-zionists' who say that if they defend the rights of the Israeli Jewish nation then they're Zionists, they respond: "So I'm a Zionist. So what?"

The impulse is clearly honourable. But the logic, I think, is faulty. "Zionism' had a clear meaning before 1948. Marxists opposed Zionism. They regarded it as a tragically mistaken attempt by the oppressed to respond to oppression, rather than as an anti-Arab imperialist conspiracy; but they opposed it.

They where right to oppose it, 1 think; and I believe Mick Ackersley and Jack Cleary would agree. But an Israeli Jewish nation now exists; and however it came into existence, it nas rights.

Crude anti-Zionists often refer to the Israeli Jewish nation as the Zionists' . They evade the issue of the rights of the Israeli Jewish nation by first reducing the Israeli Jews to a political group ("Zionists') and then reducing "Zionist' politics to the driving out of the Palestinian Arabs.

Now most Israeli Jews would accept the label "Zionist'", And historic Zionism did mean the driving out of the Palestinian Arabs. But historic Zionism also meant many other things. And the big majority of Israeli Jews are Israeli Jews not because of an ideological choice but because they were born in Israel or found Israel as a refuge from persecution. So the 'anti-Zionist' definition grossly distorts the reality.

Then the 'anti-Zionists' add an inescapably anti-semitic twist by proceeding further in the same line of argument and extending the term "Zionist' to all those (Jews) who feel a special national allegiance to the Israel Jewish nation.

Even as a gambit in debate, saying 'So then I'm a Zionist too; so what?' is a more confusing than clarifying response. Obviously we - Mick Ackersley, Jack Cleary, myself - do not feel any special national allegiance to the Israeli Jewish nation above all others. Rather, we defend the rights of that nation like all others.

The point is to separate out all the different elements blurred together in the word "Zionism' . It is crucial to insist that the Marxist opposition to historic Zionism has no bearing on the issue of the rights of the modern Israeli Jewish nation.

There is another problem. In Israeli and wider Jewish politics, "Zionism' has a current meaning which is narrower than Jack Cleary's "logical' definition as meaning "defending the right of Israel to exist (maybe with modifications)'.

The narrower meaning is: seeing the state of Israel as having some mystic mission for the redemption (physical, social or spiritual) of the whole worldwide Jewish people; and therefore seeing it as having not just rights proper to the Israeli Jewish nation as to any other nation, but special, additional rights, higher than those of other national entities.

I don't particularly advocate this narrower meaning as 'my' definition ot Zionism. But it is certainly more logical than Jack Cleary's (one can very well condemn historic Zionism yet be a 'Zionist' in Jack Cleary's definition').

And another thing: in the general British labour movement we can very well deal with the crude 'antiZionists' by saying that their use of 'Zionism' is an ideological amalgam, and by insisting on defining issues more precisely: the politics of the state of Israel, and the rights of the Israeli Jewish nation, non-Israeli Jewish identification with that nation, etc.

But it is almost impossible to participate in Israeli, or broader Jewish, politics without accepting the narrower definition of Zionism, at least provisionally. And to have 'our" definition of Zionism in which almost all Jewish and Israeli anti-Zionists, and a sizeable spectrum of Palestinian nationalists, are "Zionists', is perverse.

Martin Thomas, Sydney

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 297

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →